News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by pydry on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:21PM (#24748299)
The UK government doesn't even trust itself with test and trace data privacy: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-54328644

Without privacy guarantees people don't use it. If people don't use it the whole system fails.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by azalemeth on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:57PM (#24749452)
I work in part for the NHS, and have been told to turn off the app while in the hospital. In part, I think this is because they are scared of the effect that false positives will have on (already precarious) staffing numbers (just like the police -- which, owing to austerity, are horrendously under-manned).

That being said, I haven't installed the app. I know I "should", but I just do not trust it. I've completely and utterly lost all faith in the government, and although I have the .apk executable sitting in my downloads folder just waiting for me to disassemble it and read through it myself, I haven't yet.

It's almost as if decades of sophisticated spying and "dark practices" have conditioned the entirety of the UK to not trust their government, or something. I use a VPN (or three) at home, tor where appropriate, and root my phone and cut out the Google dial-home. It's a very big ask to get me to install a government-developed application. I just have a deep, probably irrational, fear of it watching everything I do.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by gerdesj on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:53PM (#24749815)
"... have been told to turn off the app while in the hospital."

(This is for England only, I have no idea what the rest of the UK is up to)

The algorithm the app uses is pretty simple and in your case would be going off like a siren nearly daily. It announces itself in the vicinity via bluetooth and listens for similar announcements. Each device has a random, self generated ID and this is changed regularly. If someone gets a positive test and reports via the app then their ID at the time is sent out. Apps will compare their list of known IDs and times they were seen with the positive list. Basically if your app decides that it saw a "positive" ID for something like 15 minutes or more then it will flag it to you. Then it is up to you whether to isolate, get tested etc. It is not an offence to ignore the app but it is if you ignore an official Check and Trace operative.

This is why you are told not to use it at work. The algorithm is designed to work for people going about "normal" life and your life in the NHS is not normal. It can't possibly work for you or my cousin working as a matron in a hospital. The algorithm basically measures exposure and the current thinking is that 15 mins is long enough to flag a warning. So don't stop and chat for ages in the supermarket/park/pub or whatever to your mates - say hi and use a phone later. If you do go to a pub or restaurant then you have to accept that there is a risk.

If you are worried about the sign in QR code thing not having a sign out until midnight, you can create your own home "sign in" to do the same job. See https://www.gov.uk/create-coronavirus-qr-poster .

There is no need for conspiracy theories! The source code is on Github so no need to mess with the apk. You may want to check that the source generates the .apk though. I'm not a fan of some things that have been done here but the new app is the right way to do it in my opinion. It's very, very simple and has no personally identifiable data involved. It's basically one simple rule of thumb that is good enough to semi-automate part of the C&T function. It is not good enough for your trade though and you should not use it at work.

Stay safe.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrisseaton on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:37PM (#24748427)
> Without privacy guarantees people don't use it.

The vast vast majority of people don't know anything about privacy guarantees and this does not factor into their decisions in any way.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by walterbell on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:23PM (#24749618)
To the contrary, contact tracers in many countries have been having a lot of trouble getting people to give up the names of their contacts, or even to answer contact tracers.

"Privacy" is not an abstract generic concept. It is context and consequence dependent.

When "contact data" has the monetary and social value associated with a mandatory 14-day quarantine, people accurately consider restrictions on future movement, not privacy. Those who don't, quickly learn the hard way or from a friend. They don't need the word "privacy", only "don't do that again".

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrisseaton on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:44PM (#24749767)
> To the contrary, contact tracers in many countries have been having a lot of trouble getting people to give up the names of their contacts, or even to answer contact tracers.

Where I live people put their full names, email addresses and phone numbers happily down on on a piece of paper for everyone to see!

> "Privacy" is not an abstract generic concept.

It is to these people!

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by bigiain on Sunday October 11, 2020 @08:16PM (#24750276)
> Where I live people put their full names, email addresses and phone numbers happily down on on a piece of paper for everyone to see!

Did they? Ask your woman friends. I'll bet a _lot_ of them are using fake details. They have genuine threat models that the sort of people who decide "lets just have a piece of paper with everybody's name and phone number at the front door" never have to think about.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by walterbell on Sunday October 11, 2020 @07:13PM (#24749931)
Give them a few months to experience mandatory quarantine even when symptom-free. Learning is fun!
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by jlokier on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:28AM (#24751917)
> even when symptom-free

It's really unfortunate that much of the spreading of Covid-19 may be people with no symptoms, who believe incorrectly that because they have no symptoms, they don't have it, can't have it, present no risk to anyone and certainly aren't spreading the virus.

A friend tells me they have a friend who insists on hanging out because "I can't have it, I don't have any symptoms".

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrisseaton on Sunday October 11, 2020 @07:24PM (#24749993)
> Learning is fun!

I don't get why you're being so snarky - it's actually against the rules here.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by walterbell on Sunday October 11, 2020 @07:51PM (#24750135)
It could be rephrased as "Learning is necessary"?

People are sharing names, email addresses and phone numbers based on assumptions and models of reality developed over many years, e.g. they have experienced zero observable consequences from all previous sharing of this information. Based on their historical observations, it's not illogical to continue sharing.

But policy has changed in 2020. Now the data goes into databases with a physical consequence: temporary blacklisting from work, play, school, travel, even non-essential medical treatment.

This is why people who have already been contact traced (they are already experiencing and learning the consequences) have been reluctant to give the names of their close contacts, because they know personally the consequences that will be imposed on their contacts, facilitated by their disclosure of contact names.

Until people have this first-hand learning experience, it's difficult to put the data in context. Most importantly, being contact traced does not mean they are sick or will get sick from the (possibly symptom-free and false-positive PCR test) contact being traced, yet they and their contacts would be asked to pay an expensive price.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by pydry on Sunday October 11, 2020 @04:49PM (#24748979)
It matters at least somewhat to 90% of the general public and is very important to almost 50%:

https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/sites/default/file...

So no, you're extremely wrong.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrisseaton on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:01PM (#24749063)
People will say anything in response to a question.

What do people really care about and will actually action? Very different to what you think.

Turns out 99% will use Google and Facebook and crack on despite the tracking and not really care about it.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by pydry on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:19PM (#24749194)
20% said after the Snowden revelations that the way they used their email changed "a great deal". You might have noticed that facebook engagement has completely collapsed while whatsapp (E2E encrypted, supposedly) popularity surged.

I mean, yes, I get the strong impression you don't care.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by deanCommie on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:03PM (#24749484)
Facebook engagement did not collapse because of privacy concerns.

People stopped using it because it stopped being a good way to keep in touch with friends and instead became a Bazaare containing every single person you've ever met for a millisecond. People no longer felt connected, and gravitated to more curated communication channels where they could choose who they talk to.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by skocznymroczny on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:30AM (#24753047)
Is even Facebook engagement collapsing? From my point of view, the main strength of facebook isn't even the friend networks. The main strength is that it has became a replacement for company websites. Many companies no wonder have a website or email you can contact them, all contact is done by Facebook.
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by ulisesrmzroche on Sunday October 11, 2020 @08:39PM (#24750400)
You have any actual data backing up the claim about FB engagement? I don’t think there’s any validity to that
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrisseaton on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:29PM (#24749258)
> 20% said after the Snowden revelations

I really struggle to believe that 20% of people have heard of Snowden in any meaningful way to form an opinion.

I'm picturing 20% of the people who live on my street. When I talk to them I don't get the impression most of them follow the news in that much depth. Many have been retired and zoned out from any kind of public life for many years. (Not a criticism - maybe they have other interests than me. Maybe they're happier than me for that?)

> I get the strong impression you don't care.

No, sorry you've imagine that out of nowhere. It isn't implied by anything I've said - I haven't talked about my personal beliefs at all.

I'm just a realist about what the people around me outside the tech and media bubble are reading and thinking.

Do you live on a street in the Valley with 100 Google engineers? Most people don't.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by pydry on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:51PM (#24749402)
>I really struggle to believe that 20% of people have heard of Snowden

72% in the UK.

>Do you live on a street in the Valley

You don't... really believe in polling do you?

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrisseaton on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:55PM (#24749442)
> You don't... really believe in polling do you?

People say all kinds of things in response to polling. That's why polling gets it wrong again and again. For example... the 2016 election.

Guess what: phone my 90 year old neighbours with a question about Edward Snowden... they aren't going to even pick up the phone!

Look at what people PRACTICALLY do rather than what they poll to do. You'll find it doesn't match.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by tialaramex on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:21PM (#24749606)
> People say all kinds of things in response to polling.

That's correct. The US is currently conducting a poll to decide most of the composition of its government (including some local and many national political positions) and as you claim, the voters will say "all kinds of things".

But the answers stick anyway. Even though they say "all kinds of things" you live in a democracy and those "all kinds of things" decides the rules. Now, given that I'd be trying to maybe get them to say smarter things, but if you prefer to just smirk about it I cannot stop you.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrisseaton on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:26PM (#24749644)
> but if you prefer to just smirk about it I cannot stop you

I don't understand where this snark is coming from?

Am I saying something that you don't wish was true?

The reality is... most people out there don't care about privacy nor Snowden. The reality is most of them are trying to make enough to feed their families this week plus pay their bills and don't have the energy to think about anything else. I'm not smirking about it. I didn't express any opinion about it. I'm telling you the facts!

Are you assuming I think this is good? Where did you read that? You've imagined it!

You're confusing a reality check with an opinion on how I think things should be!

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by QuesnayJr on Sunday October 11, 2020 @08:08PM (#24750222)
How... how wrong do you think the polls were in 2016? Clinton won the popular vote by 3 million votes, and Trump's electoral college victory was narrow.
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrisseaton on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:47AM (#24752297)
> how wrong do you think the polls were in 2016?

This is a bizarre question. They predicted Clinton would win. She didn’t.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by mattbee on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:53PM (#24749422)
People in the UK are writing their names & mobile numbers down at the door to most restaurants now - just one big long piece of paper that everyone can read.

I'm sure people say it's important in the abstract, but not in practice, and not right now.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by bigiain on Sunday October 11, 2020 @08:14PM (#24750256)
If it's anything like here in Sydney, people are writing some name and some phone number down. Every woman I know uses a fake name, and most of them are using fake numbers too.

Covid risks are _way_ lower here than risks of random creeps misusing names/numbers of women...

I'm less affected by those particular risks, but I still use a burner Twilio SMS number and a burner gmail address that doesn't get used for anything else, with plus addressing to help try identify where a leak happened. If that account starts getting spam to [email protected] or [email protected], I might get a smoking gun about who leaked it.

If the spammers are cleaning their lists of that well-enough-known email tracking trick and sending enough smtp to make the address a problem to use, I can just walk away from that gmail account and set up a new one.

I'm contemplating building an automated system of "rolling 4 week validity email addresses" that I can easily enough work out on-the-spot, perhaps month/week-of-month encoding so I'd use [email protected] this week (102 being october 2nd week) and only have the addresses live long enough for contact tracing purposes. Perhaps using something t5hat works the same as gmail's "plus addressing" but different enough that spammers list cleaning tools won't know about it. That'd involve running my own mail server though, and the risks here right now are so low (in the single digit cases per day in a city of 5million people) that I'm more motivated to just lie on the contact forms instead...

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by johnr2 on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:34PM (#24749702)
> It matters at least somewhat to 90% of the general public and is very important to almost 50%: https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/sites/default/file...

From the linked web page: "sample size 1006 respondents". Given the UK population of around 68 million that seems a small sample.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by dTal on Sunday October 11, 2020 @10:22PM (#24750860)
The size of the UK population is irrelevant to the statistics. Absolute sample size determines the expected error, and a thousand people is plenty provided they are selected at random.
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by rsynnott on Sunday October 11, 2020 @09:55PM (#24750760)
Assuming it was a properly conducted poll(I have no idea if it was or not), you get surprisingly accurate results with that sort of sample size.
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by Gibbon1 on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:30PM (#24748364)
I feel like we need to extend the laws we have that govern credit reporting agencies to these other businesses that aggregate personal data. Which hopefully will put them right out of business.
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by chrismatheson on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:14PM (#24749159)
Are credit bureaus any better? I mean I know equifax messed up royally and I have no reason to believe that all the rest aren’t pushing on every conceivable limit of the law to maximise the profit to be made from information they scrape about me without my consent, then pay lip service to protecting it.
Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by Gibbon1 on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:36PM (#24749713)
You can see your credit report, challenge information you think is incorrect. And there are restrictions on what information they can collect on you. You can lock your report as well. Some types of pulls require your signature.

None of these other grey market data collection firms have to do any of that. One thing I noticed is these guys are collecting data that would fall under HIPPA.

Go ahead do some searches for Hepatitis C and then look at your ads on Facebook.

Re:Contact-tracing data harvested from pubs and restaurants ... by nicbou on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:13AM (#24752404)
This is also the case in Germany. It's why you have all sorts of different ID numbers, and need to sign documents to allow different offices to communicate.