News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by actuator on Sunday October 11, 2020 @11:58AM (#24746659)
Also, it runs afoul of sections of GDPR.

I don't agree that Spotify has to let users transfer Spotify curated playlists as that is a business strength. Songshift seems to show Spotify curated playlists on their homepage like Discover Weekly so I can see why Spotify won't like this.

But if my understanding of GDPR is right they have to allow users to transfer playlists created by themselves.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by tpmx on Sunday October 11, 2020 @12:07PM (#24746737)
Right. Forgot that.

Regarding GDPR and data portability:

In practise you can expect to receive a (link to a) zip file via email with a bunch of XML documents after going through a convoluted dance. Also, it often takes some time (days) to receive the data. Basically, nothing that can easily be automated by a third part service - you need user auth of the requesting user to access the data.)

"You must comply with a request for data portability without undue delay and at the latest within one month of receipt of the request"

I guess it's because data portability isn't trivial, and it was wasn't the key aspect of GDPR.

As a contrast: The EU mobile number portability legislation says: max 1 working day.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by iav on Sunday October 11, 2020 @09:09PM (#24750537)
Carriers pay to port numbers to a neutral third party that maintains the Number Portability service. In the US, that used to be $6 per number port (which is basically just a DB row update operation) but a new vendor has reduced it by more than half. Carriers view that expense as pocket change as subscriber acquisition cost is well over $100 in total.

Without a legislative mandate and a third party integration partner that assures the port is successful, seems unlikely that a market leader like Spotify would ever allow them to exist.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by actuator on Sunday October 11, 2020 @12:17PM (#24746815)
Yeah, data portability is hard to define as a strict standard as it is extremely product specific.

Even when we implemented it for my last company, we did JSON exports on signed S3 paths. I thought structured data was the easiest way for any competitor or user to use their data.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by tpmx on Sunday October 11, 2020 @12:23PM (#24746866)
I feel they could have included a clause that would let a designated third party access the extracted data on the requester's behalf in an automated way.

I think it could have worked pretty well to keep it as vague as that. (The auth aspects would need more detail, obviously.)

I don't think data format fragmentation is a big issue (just implement adapters for the top five competitors in your market...), but rather the impossibility of doing it in a quick and seamless manner on behalf of someone wanting to migrate their data to your service from some other service.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by actuator on Sunday October 11, 2020 @02:53PM (#24748087)
> I feel they could have included a clause that would let a designated third party access the extracted data on the requester's behalf in an automated way.

Yeah, this would have been nice. I am not sure if legally you could enforce that as automation itself is vague and depends on the source and target both.

> I don't think data format fragmentation is a big issue (just implement adapters for the top five competitors in your market...), but rather the impossibility of doing it in a quick and seamless manner on behalf of someone wanting to migrate their data to your service from some other service.

I think if companies were being honest in their efforts for data portability, as a first step they would not try to reap the benefit of the 30 day window by as much as they can.

For most, it should take mins or hours to get the export yet the best turnaround I have seen from any service has been from Tinder, it was I think 3 days.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by watermelon0 on Sunday October 11, 2020 @06:03PM (#24749481)
This really depends on the service. In my experience, Netflix and Facebook took only a few hours to export the data.
Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by sokoloff on Sunday October 11, 2020 @08:57PM (#24750478)
> just implement adapters for the top five competitors in your market

Is there anything to prevent the export file format from shifting regularly? You know, for ongoing product improvement reasons, naturally.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by saagarjha on Sunday October 11, 2020 @04:48PM (#24748968)
Which ones? GDPR guarantees "right to data portability", not "right to an open API". I'm sure they could give you a CSV if you personally write to them and still be compliant.
[dead]
Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by tpmx on Sunday October 11, 2020 @02:33PM (#24747948)
Lol. A jingoist.
Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by jtbayly on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:06PM (#24748200)
I’m pretty sure it’s a violation of community standards to use a person’s country of origin as an insult or slur. Are you intentionally trying to denigrate a people group?
Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by tpmx on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:08PM (#24748208)
I apologize. I edited the comment accordingly.
Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by jtbayly on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:12PM (#24748223)
Lol. Nice.

Anyway, let me know when the GDPR actually helps with something instead of just making the internet more of a usability train wreck.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by tpmx on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:18PM (#24748268)
I'm pretty sure it has helped a lot already.

The key part is the "the don't keep data around forever just because you can" part.

Sure, the GDPR got a bit bloated, but I honestly believe most europeans lives got a little bit better because of it.

Edit: I think you're thinking about that horrible cookie warning law. That one needs to burned to the ground.

Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by yoavm on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:58PM (#24748590)
It's not even just European lives that got better because of GDPR, we're all benefiting from having big companies forced to comply with it. I have used the "Right to erasure" multiple times with American companies just by saying I'm from Europe.
Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by tpmx on Sunday October 11, 2020 @04:21PM (#24748776)
Awesome hack :) How are they going to begin to validate the you're a EU citizen?
Re:A Note about Spotify Transfers by fuzxi on Sunday October 11, 2020 @05:15PM (#24749162)
It's probably easier for most companies to just comply with all requests than to bother with verifying the citizenship of each requester.