News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Forearm artery reveals human evolution continues? by bonoboTP on Saturday October 10, 2020 @06:37PM (#24742399)
Do I understand correctly that their observations are compatible with the possibility that some ethnic groups have more of this phenotype and these ethnic groups are becoming a larger percentage of the world population in general? This would make the story about the artery a red herring.

For example if Northern Europeans started reproducing at a higher rate, could we say that humanity is evolving more and more lactose tolerance? I would say that would be very misleading.

My question is, does their methodology tell apart the following effects:

- The new artery is spreading across the board in various places, e.g. there is a general environmental selection pressure for random mutations in this direction, OR

- Populations that have it or don't have it are reproducing at different rates, possibly for totally unrelated reasons like socioeconomic ones.

Re:Forearm artery reveals human evolution continues? by mci on Saturday October 10, 2020 @06:49PM (#24742472)
> My question is, does their methodology tell apart the following effects: [...]

First and foremost, their curve fitting, disguised as race-agnostic methodology, ignores the number of studies of the median artery in Africa 100 years ago (zero) and now (many).