News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Friday October 09, 2020 @05:26PM (#24734622)
> The reality, though, is that none of the proposed energy storage solutions are easier than just building nuclear power plants.

This doesn't appear to be the case, or at least doesn't appear to be the case for much longer, when renewables are multiple times cheaper than nuclear.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Friday October 09, 2020 @05:41PM (#24734720)
Renewables are cheap when they make up a small percentage of total power generation. Solar is cheap when it's only providing supplemental power during the day, same with wind. Using them as a primary source of energy requires staggering amounts of storage, and proposals to fulfill these demands exist either on paper or in the form of prototypes 4-5 orders of magnitude smaller than what is required.

I've repeatedly [1] [2] addressed the shortcomings of your assumption that hydrogen will deliver low cost storage, in particular electrolysis and compression remains only ~30-40% efficient, underground storage is not widespread, and existing infrastructure to transport and storage methane cannot be used for hydrogen.

At this point, claiming renewables + storage is a solution to decarbonizing the economy is analogous to saying fusion is a solution. Yes, it's possible and we are familiar with the physics of how to make it work. And if it works, then yes it's a good solution. But it doesn't currently work, and it's unknown whether or not it will work in the foreseeable future. Technology that's 10-20 years away tends to stay 10-20 years a way for much loner than 10-20 years.

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23735379

2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24619197

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by reitzensteinm on Saturday October 10, 2020 @12:06AM (#24736623)
Your "repeated" refutations include a claim of $1400 per kWh-year of hydrogen storage with a link to a report [1]. That seemed way too high for me so I grabbed the report - which, by the way, argues that hydrogen is economical for storage of spilled wind - and have no idea where you got this figure from.

It appears you've mixed up kW and kWh at the very least. The figure you're reading also appears to include the cost of buying the electricity at market rates, which is shown to not be economical. But it isn't what parent argued for, and you explicitly state it does not include.

Reading further in to the report, it breaks down the capital cost of a hydrogen system minus storage at $550/kW, and notes the very low cost of underground storage at large scales (for smaller scales, it argues for using tanks and being geographically independent).

So you disagreed with parent, threw out a nonsensical figure and linked to a report as proof that agrees with them, not you.

And hey, it looks like someone informed you of your mistake 3 months ago [2], which you didn't bother to reply to or correct yourself.

This is a repeated theme with your accounts (your main and your sockpuppet). Every time I dig in to the numbers you throw out I get a sour taste in my mouth that you've caused me to waste my time. I believe that you are arguing in bad faith, cherry picking whatever numbers you can find, in context or not, to make a pro nuclear case. Which is a bit sad, because I think there are still strong (but dwindling) cases to be made for nuclear.

[1] https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23741288

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Saturday October 10, 2020 @02:45AM (#24737095)
Capital cost is the initial cost to build this system. The figure for comes from figure 14. The cost estimates are $3,000 with current technology. This works out to $500 per KWh 20 years system. To match the lifespan of a nuclear plant (typically 60 to 80 years), this works out to $1,500 to $2,000 per KWh when factoring the limited life span of the storage.

Regarding the reply with no response, timestamps get more coarse grained the further in the past you get. This reply could easily be weeks after my initial comment, and I would have explained how I arrived at these figures if I has read it.

Meanwhile, glaring inaccuracies like calming that existing natural gas infrastructure can be used to transport hydrogen go unmentioned. Or that "hardly anyone is building nuclear" when in fact most of the world by population is. And if we're talking about cherry-picking pfdietz incessantly cherry picks the Vogtle and Flamanville plants as though they're representative of historic nuclear costs. You arrive at the conclusion that I'm arguing in bad faith, while conveniently ignoring these issues with the claims I'm arguing against.

This exchange makes me sad, too. Solar and wind serve as useful temporary mitigation of carbon output, even though they don't pave a way to full decarbonization. A hydrogen economy has a place to fulfill demand where energy density is necessary, like in transportation. But trying to advocate pipe-dream projects like storing tens of terawatt hours worth of energy in hydrogen really makes me wonder whether solar and wind advocates really have a grasp on the engineering challenges they're facing. Especially when these plans rest on outright falsehoods, like the claim that we can using existing natural gas pipes for hydrogen.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by reitzensteinm on Saturday October 10, 2020 @03:19AM (#24737179)
Right, that's the wrong figure to use in the context of the linked debate. It's the cost to operate the plant, including buying power at market rates.

The "spilled wind" costs are the cost of the plant itself used in the manner described, which equals $1400/kW - actually, this is probably where you got the number originally - or $233/kWh. However, this is over the lifetime of the plant, meaning the storage is closer to $12/kWh per year.

That's not exactly cheap. You have to overbuild renewables to have the extra energy to store in it, and it's probably only going to cycle a few dozen times a year. Plus the $12/kWh figure likely represents (the study does not specify) the energy of the gas before conversion back to electricity which is lossy.

But adding extra storage is cheap compared to adding extra power, so unlike with lithium ion batteries you can actually feasibly build weeks worth of storage in to the system.

So, I'm not trying to say the numbers are great. I'm not saying this is what we should do. But there's a vast gap between the $1400 you quoted and the $12 figure which - at least I believe - is the correct number to use for this discussion.

There are absolutely tons of people (especially on HN) that trivialize the problems around rolling out renewables. Probably the majority of my posts on the topic have actually been on the other side, pointing out issues or complaining about subsidies instead of carbon taxes.

But I really think you've gone 180 degrees in the other direction and the numbers you use make it seem an order of magnitude harder than it is. I think even more extreme than using the worst Western nuclear cost overruns as representative of the intrinsic cost of nuclear.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Saturday October 10, 2020 @09:09AM (#24738736)
For other cost figures for hydrogen storage, see the options and linked references at

https://model.energy/

You can also use that site (and its weather time series) and play with the assumptions to see when nuclear can be made competitive with renewables + storage at supplying steady power output in various places, under a set of simplifying assumptions that tend to favor nuclear. You will find that hydrogen tends to be more important in high latitude places using wind.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Saturday October 10, 2020 @12:22PM (#24739967)
$12 per kilowatt hour, per year. You then need to multiply by the number of years that this storage system needs to be online. Again, if we're comparing against the alternative of building a nuclear plant, this is 60 to 80 years. Neglecting to factor in the required lifespan artificially deflates the price drastically. And again this figure of $12 per KWh per year is for the "spilled wind" scenario - that is, the assumption that the electricity input is provided at zero cost.

The other poster also did more than just cherry pick particularly expensive plants. Among other things, they claimed that existing natural gas infrastructure can be used to transport hydrogen. This is simply untrue, hydrogen would corrode metal pipes used for natural gas. There's a factor of 2,000 less hydrogen pipelines. Probably even less overall infrastructure if you count natural gas transported by rail and LNG shipping.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by reitzensteinm on Saturday October 10, 2020 @06:26PM (#24742312)
But your claim was $1400 per kilowatt hour, per year, when electricity is free. All I'm doing is correcting that - the actual figure is $12, with the exact details you specified, sourced from the report that you linked.

Your quote:

"Current estimates place this at $1,400 per KWh per year for the average case assuming that the electricity provided is free [1]."

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23739820

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Saturday October 10, 2020 @07:49PM (#24742785)
Sure, that should refer to the lifetime cost, not per year. That's the cost when you cover the yearly cost over the span of the desired lifetime, which is what's relevant when you're comparing short lives systems vs. long lived systems.
Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Saturday October 10, 2020 @04:35PM (#24741701)
> they claimed that existing natural gas infrastructure can be used to transport hydrogen.

Are you referring to me there? Because I never said that.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Saturday October 10, 2020 @07:46PM (#24742759)
> Geological formations suitable for storage of hydrogen are quite widespread. They're basically identical to the formations that are already used to store natural gas.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24621709

> Not really. It has lower energy/mole. There is the possibility that if CO2 is present that microorganisms could react the two to make methane. But aside from that, where is this much greater complexity coming from? The equipment required for storing either is similar.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24626876

> And did you read my post? There is already a great deal of equipment for manipulating hydrogen on an industrial scale. What, did you think they rip that stuff out every month? The issue you are raising is already well solved.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24633530

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Saturday October 10, 2020 @08:07PM (#24742864)
None of that says that the existing natural gas infrastructure can be used to distribute hydrogen.

It's remarkable that you make a post like that without realizing how it shreds what little credibility you have left.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Saturday October 10, 2020 @08:13PM (#24742895)
Then what did you mean by, "The equipment required for storing either is similar" and "there is already a great deal of equipment for manipulating hydrogen"? Interpreting this as saying that natural gas infrastructure can be repurposed to work with hydrogen makes sense even if it is based on a false assumption that this is feasible. This claim that we have a great deal of equipment for manipulating hydrogen would be true if natural gas and hydrogen infrastructure were interchangeable.

But if you do understand that hydrogen and natural gas infrastructure are different, then this statement is just totally unsubstantiated. You knew that our hydrogen infrastructure is several orders of magnitude smaller, but you just say the complete opposite?

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Saturday October 10, 2020 @08:35PM (#24742981)
I see english is not your first language. If it were, you would know that "similar" and "identical" are not synonyms.

> Interpreting this as saying that natural gas infrastructure can be repurposed to work with hydrogen makes sense

It absolutely does not make sense. It's a bit of illogic you apparently are not capable of recognizing as a non sequitur.

BTW, the equipment we have for handling hydrogen is not necessarily in pipelines (although the US does have many miles of hydrogen pipeline even today). It's in ammonia synthesis plants. It's in oil refineries. It's in chlor-alkali cells. The world economy makes many millions of tons of hydrogen each year, and that hydrogen is manipulated with equipment that exists. Compressors, pipes, pumps, valves, sensors... all those exist in forms that work with hydrogen.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Saturday October 10, 2020 @09:06PM (#24743090)
Resorting to ad hominems only demonstrates that you're not interested in engaging productively.

So this claim about having infrastructure to manipulate hydrogen is referring to the chemical industry, where hydrogen frequently used as an input. You're right that the chemical industry does use hydrogen and we have infrastructure to use it in the Haber process, and refining hydrocarbons and more. But this infrastructure doesn't translate to using hydrogen as a form of energy storage. The US has less than 1,000 miles of hydrogen pipeline [1]. Most hydrogen production facilities are located close to the point of demand. Our experience manipulating hydrogen has taught us that it's important to minimize to minimize the amount of transport required.

Also, almost all of these many millions of tons of hydrogen produced each year are produced through steam reformation [2]. This is not carbon neutral, and renewable hydrogen production must be done through electrolysis or thermochemical hydrogen production instead.

By comparison, there's a larger need to transport hydrogen if we're using hydrogen as a form of energy storage. Hydrogen storage is underground, and electrolysis needs to be done by a source of water. The source and destination have different required geographic features - transport is unavoidable. Alternatively you could pipe the water to the electrolysis plant, but then you're moving 9 times as much mass through the pipeline - water is 1 part hydrogen to 8 parts oxygen by mass.

So the claim that we have extensive infrastructure in manipulating hydrogen wasn't a misunderstanding in that natural gas infrastructure can be used to transport hydrogen. It was a misunderstanding in that the infrastructure used to manipulate hydrogen in the context of the chemical industry translates into infrastructure for renewable hydrogen production, and hydrogen transport and storage. It doesn't: most of our hydrogen is produced through steam reformation, and our hydrogen infrastructure is built around minimizing need to transport and store hydrogen.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_infrastructure#:~:tex....

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by reitzensteinm on Saturday October 10, 2020 @11:37PM (#24743550)
If water access is the bottleneck, you can build storage and reuse it. 1 GWh of hydrogen is equal to 30 tons, or 270 tons of water. That's so small you can literally order a prefab off the internet here in Australia, installed and delivered for $10k.

Extrapolated, that would represent $0.01/kWh in capital costs, or a complete rounding error of costs over the lifetime of the plant. You could even truck it in from a thousand miles away without really impacting the cost very much.

To explore the problem a different way, here in Australia, 8 million megaliters of water was used in farming in the last year. Total energy consumption (not just electricity) in the same period was 1714 TWh.

Storing 3 weeks of our energy needs would require 26,700 megaliters of water be converted to hydrogen, or 0.3% of the amount yearly used in farming, already distributed in regional areas.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Sunday October 11, 2020 @01:16PM (#24747356)
0.3% of water used for irrigation would be totally fine.

The heat of formation of water is 13 MJ/kg. If we can convert hydrogen to power at 50% HHV efficiency, this means 1000 TWh of storage would require hydrogen from about 1/4 of a cubic kilometer of water. This is small compared to the water used in the US for irrigation (about 100 cubic kilometers per year). (It would be somewhat higher than this due to the need to reject waste heat from the bottoming cycle of the CC plant, and at the electrolysers and hydrogen compressors.)

A key point, though, is that nuclear uses water too, for cooling. For every MJ of power from a reactor, 2 MJ of waste heat is produced, and this heat goes out the cooling towers (there are dry cooling solutions, but they make nuclear even more expensive, less efficient, and less competitive). The heat of evaporation of water is 2.26 MJ/m^3, so 1000 TWh of power from nuclear would require evaporating 1.6 cubic kilometers of cooling water.

But it's worse than that. Hydrogen only has to handle the last slice of power demand (that 500 TWh is about 1/9th the US annual power consumption; your 3 weeks out of 52 would be even less), but nuclear would have to produce all of it, or at least a major chunk (and the reactors have to operate at high capacity factor or the cost of their power becomes even more ludicrous). So the water use of nuclear would actually be an order of magnitude higher than that.

The water argument is an argument for wind and solar (and hydrogen), not an argument for nuclear.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Sunday October 11, 2020 @01:54AM (#24744010)
The challenge lies in moving the water, not in building a container to store it.

> You could even truck it in from a thousand miles away without really impacting the cost very much.

Lets' do the math. Trucking costs ~$.15 per short ton per mile as per Google. So shipping 270 tons over 1,000 miles works out to $40,000. And you're using the thermal energy density of hydrogen, not the electrical energy density - as in, accounting for inefficiency of electricity generation. 1 GWh thermal is typically 500 MWh electrical for both fuel cells and turbines. The actual cost would be double that, given that most systems are 40-60% efficient. So if by "without really impacting the cost vey much" you mean "increasing the cost by a factor of 5-9x", then sure. Moving large amounts of water is energy intensive, most infrastructure built to move water relies on gravity to move water from alpine reservoirs to lowlands. And unless you're capturing the output of whatever you're using to transform hydrogen back into electricity, then this is a recurring cost not a capital cost. This is easier to do for some implementations, like electrochemical cells, but much harder for gas turbines.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by reitzensteinm on Sunday October 11, 2020 @03:32AM (#24744290)
Yeah, I mean in the case where you're recapturing the water. Trucking it to use it once is madness, and storage isn't really relevant if you've got a pipeline or a river to draw from.

You're totally right about thermal vs electrical, even with a fuel cell.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Sunday October 11, 2020 @01:18PM (#24747380)
If the volume involved is high enough to be problematic, it's high enough to justify building pipelines. The cost of trucking is irrelevant.
Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by reitzensteinm on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @10:37AM (#24776993)
Right. I was just sketching out that you could build it self contained in a desert if you really had to and still make it economical.

Ad absurdum only, not a serious suggestion.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Friday October 09, 2020 @06:41PM (#24735156)
Renewables have lower LCoE. Intermittency adds a cost, but the add is finite, and if the LCoE difference is large enough they beat nuclear.

You will notice hardly anyone is building nuclear power plants. They can see the writing on the wall. As renewables and storage technologies continue to get cheaper, nuclear will be pushed aside.

Yes, you've repeatedly claimed I'm wrong. You're the one who is wrong. Your objections are spurious, as I've repeatedly explained.

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Friday October 09, 2020 @06:53PM (#24735234)
> You will notice hardly anyone is building nuclear power plants

If by "hardly anyone" you mean "most of the world" [1]. Most of the world by population lives in a country building nuclear power. This claim is throughly divorced from reality.

> Yes, you've repeatedly claimed I'm wrong. You're the one who is wrong. Your objections are spurious, as I've repeatedly explained.

Yet you neglect to actually point out any such inaccuracies, just insist I'm wrong without any specific criticism.

Meanwhile, I've actually pointed out which of your claims are false: the notion that we can use existing hydrogen infrastructure ignoring the problems of hydrogen corrosion, assuming that underground hydrogen storage is ubiquitous, and trusting highly optimistic claims on the efficiency of electrolysis.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_by_country#/me...

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by pfdietz on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:33PM (#24735771)
> If by "hardly anyone" you mean "most of the world" [1].

You mean, 19 countries? Maybe if you go by population. In many cases, the reasons for building reactors are clearly not because it's cheapest (UAE, I'm looking at you). There's clear regret in the US about Vogtle and Summer, and in France about Flamanville. (For that matter, in India about the cost overruns on their latest Russian PWRs.)

> Yet you neglect to actually point out any such inaccuracies, just insist I'm wrong without any specific criticism.

Go to those links you provided, where I refuted your cavalcade of bogus arguments. You seem to think that concatenating a series of invalid claims somehow turns that into a valid claim.

The technique you were employing is well known, it's called a "Gish Gallop".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop

Re:Separating Hype from Hydrogen: EU's 6GW Electrolyzer Plan by Manfredo_1 on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:59PM (#24735893)
I've refuted each and every one of your claims about the feasibility of hydrogen storage. For the second time, you claim that my claims are invalid, without actually specifying what's invalid and why.

You claim to have explained why my criticisms are wrong, but you've done no such thing. In the more recent thread, you insist we have experience manipulating hydrogen at great scale. But I point out we actually have 2,000 times less hydrogen infrastructure. And I point out that 6% of natural gas production used for hydrogen production isn't all that impressive because most of it is used for heating, only a fraction of it is actually used in the steam reformation process. Explaining that our hydrogen infrastructure is orders of magnitude smaller than our natural gas infrastructure, you go silent. This hardly looks like a refutation.

If you want to actually refute any of my claims please do so. But you're just insisting I'm wrong without even bothering to specific what I'm wrong about.