News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A... by hnracer on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:26PM (#24732226)
This sounds like the God Of The Gaps line of fallacious reasoning. Once we figure out where radium came from then God will be inserted just before that new discovery, ad infinitum, turtles all the way down
Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A... by rtkwe on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:32PM (#24732291)
Sure but it's a way to integrate science and religion and ultimately science doesn't really have an way to answer 'why' for any of this. Even if there's not an actual answer it just happens to be that way and we're a happy little accident of the universe for a lot of people that's kind of unsatisfying. Even if they're wrong to people want to ascribe meaning to their lives, it's why philosophy and religion will probably never leave us.
Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A... by jandrese on Friday October 09, 2020 @04:10PM (#24733912)
The God of the Gaps reasoning always seemed dangerous to me. It creates a system where each scientific discovery diminishes God, pitting religious people against the advancement of science. As the gaps grow smaller so does God. In the long run you're in danger of reducing God to some mathematical constants.
Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A... by throwaway123x2 on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:35PM (#24733576)
Sure, that's the Prime Mover theory, which would be extraordinarily hard to prove or disprove. I don't think it's fallacious reasoning.
Re:1000 Years Before Darwin, Islamic Scholars Were Writing A... by hnracer on Friday October 09, 2020 @05:25PM (#24734606)
It's fallacious to put God one step before everything we don't know (radium, etc), while forgetting the numerous times this was done in the past (rainbows, etc) only to be demonstrated false once science advances. That's quite different to the Prime Mover hypothesis.