News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Memcmp being wrongly stripped like strcmp by Dylan16807 on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:33AM (#24727699)
A bunch of mistakes all in the same area mean you're doing something wrong, moreso than "everyone makes mistakes". And if it's an accident, and not caused by someone overworking you, then it falls under the umbrella of "incompetence". That doesn't mean you're a failure in general, it means you weren't up to doing this particular work at this moment in your life.
Re:Memcmp being wrongly stripped like strcmp by Someone on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:55AM (#24727798)
Depends on how much work you did in that area, and even if the proportion of mistakes is high, it doesn’t necessarily imply incompetence. Could be a bad day.

Also, I would guess gcc does code reviews. If so, gcc seems to be full of incompetent programmers, making it a miracle that this thing can even compile hello world. I don’t think that’s the case.

Re:Memcmp being wrongly stripped like strcmp by Dylan16807 on Friday October 09, 2020 @04:17AM (#24727892)
If you had that bad of a day while being extremely "productive", and never double checked, then that falls under the umbrella of incompetence.

> If so, gcc seems to be full of incompetent programmers

Are you bristling at a word that looks like an insult and then ignoring what I'm actually saying? I specifically said you can be incompetent at a particular thing at a particular moment in time and that it is not a summary of you in general!

Re:Memcmp being wrongly stripped like strcmp by rbanffy on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:29AM (#24729698)
"Incompetent", in special if you use it without any further qualification, is not usually meant as "incompetent at a particular thing at a particular time".

I'd say that pretty much everyone is completely incompetent when it comes to correctly implement a complicated piece of software like GCC. OTOH, the people who develop GCC are incredibly competent at what they do because the compiler does insanely complicated things the vast majority of the human race would struggle to comprehend and, yet, its surprisingly correct, with the occasional bug and confusion here and there.

We all work at the limits of our wits. Right now I'm waiting for a timeout so I can continue to test a hypothesis. If I am lucky, I'll be right and the system will malfunction in the way I expect it to. I'd say my chances at this point are 50/50.

Re:Memcmp being wrongly stripped like strcmp by Dylan16807 on Friday October 09, 2020 @02:03PM (#24732614)
In the context of malice vs. incompetence, malice certainly doesn't refer to an innate quality you possess all the time, so why would the alternative mean that?

> with the occasional bug and confusion here and there

And the point of this thread was talking about a big batch of bugs, the opposite of "occasional".

Re:Memcmp being wrongly stripped like strcmp by shawnz on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:09AM (#24728736)
Maybe that area just has a high complexity, making mistakes there more likely?