News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by Scoundreller on Thursday October 08, 2020 @05:51PM (#24724300)
> Found image 1 at offset 20000

> Enter '1', '2', or 'p' within 2 seconds or take default...

Wait, tens or hundreds of millions of cable modem startups are delayed by 2s on each start just in case somebody has soldered up a serial interface and wants to load a different image?

Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by marcan_42 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @09:48PM (#24725906)
Wait until you find out your Mac initializes bluetooth in the BIOS and looks for a keyboard and checks for keys pressed before trying to boot anything, in case you're holding down option to go into the boot menu using a wireless keyboard.

This is pretty much a universal feature of any device with a bootloader and an OS. If it weren't there, you wouldn't be able to diagnose anything. 2 seconds is reasonable.

Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by bityard on Thursday October 08, 2020 @07:40PM (#24725149)
Cable modems are powered up and online 99.9% of the time, little to no productivity is being lost here. If it makes the engineers' lives easier, up to 5 seconds would be totally reasonable, in my opinion.

If you want to talk about human productivity being pointlessly wasted while waiting for things to load, let's start with modern web apps.

Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by dheera on Friday October 09, 2020 @12:42AM (#24726896)
That or just simply the sheer percentage of Comcast downtime, or the percentage of time their stupid DHCP servers give me only an IPv6 and not an IPv4 address, and their support just gives me the "Is the power button in the on position" type BS and the support person doesn't seem to even know what DHCP is.
Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by budgi4 on Friday October 09, 2020 @02:27AM (#24727378)
Or try measuring mankind's productivity wasted in trying to insert a USB cable the correct side up.
Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by MauranKilom on Friday October 09, 2020 @06:09PM (#24734930)
Fun fact: The USB logo should be facing you when the cable is inserted in the correct orientation. Ever since learning that, the magic "turn it around three times" has stopped happening to me.
Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by toast0 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @07:45PM (#24725191)
That wouldn't surprise me. How much of a cable modem's life is spent booting? Probably not much. Fiddling with the bootloader to make it faster on production hardware would make it harder to debug if needed. They did leave the UART pins accessible on the board, so they may have expected to possibly need to tftp boot the boards in extreme circumstances.

You could make that require a jumper somewhere, but 2 seconds added to the boot time, when a working modem probably doesn't boot more than once a month is simply not a lot of time.

Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by wlesieutre on Thursday October 08, 2020 @08:24PM (#24725448)
That's probably wasted 3 seconds of my time this year
Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by Scoundreller on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:50AM (#24727215)
I’m a weirdo that has a brunch of phantom loads on a power bar that I flip off when I leave for a while.

You should consider cycling more often if your ISP purges IP assignment records and tries to assign new IPs upon reconnect.

Mine keeps records for 30 days after lease expiry (usually your session end date)

Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by notsuoh on Thursday October 08, 2020 @08:40PM (#24725540)
100M cable modems though, we could have solved world hunger had we combined all of our collective lost time from this.
Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by wlesieutre on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:37PM (#24732342)
If we're trying to save as much time as possible from our internet service, let's talk about Comcast's call center hold times where I've wasted orders of magnitude more time than waiting for my modem to boot
Re:Show HN: I reverse engineered my cable modem and turned i... by Scoundreller on Thursday October 08, 2020 @09:16PM (#24725722)
That’s about 76 years of waiting each year for 100m monthly reboots.

I think the 3 cents saved on a jumper block per unit is fine, but since we’re talking about a UART requiring soldering you’re access, holding two lines together to access debug mode seems fine.