The contrary point of view is that this means that either:
1. crapIBM will need to pay betterIBM for access to continue using the ERP, QRadar, Remedy, licenses, etc tools they use today. This is better for betterIBM and worse for crapIBM
2. crapIBM will need to stop using betterIBM's tools, and have to quickly negotiate new licenses/tools and spend 6+ months of their first fiscal year just moving platforms (moving SAP has often been a 2 year failed IT challenge, good luck). This will make crapIBM continue to look worse, making betterIBM's leadership look good for divesting themselves of it.
It's in nobody's interest for "betterIBM" to succeed at the greater expense of "crapIBM". With so much shared ownership (at least in the medium-term, practically speaking), shareholders want both to succeed.
That's the whole point -- shareholders think both halves will do better as separate entities, and it's in nobody's interest for one half to exploit the other.
Surely your "crapIBM" will continue to have access to "betterIBM"'s tools at a reasonable price, but they'll also be free to migrate to better ones, as they choose, at the pace that is most profitable for them.
It's win-win because that's the entire point of the split in the first place. The two resulting entities aren't even competing with each other, they're in totally different markets.
A big point of splitting up is so that (in both directions, to the extent that it applies) cross-unit costs aren't baked into operations. Subsidies like you suggest directly undermine that.
[1] https://www.pwc.com/m1/en/blog/intangibles-tax-risks-opportu...
[2] https://prospect.org/economy/decisive-tax-defeat-for-the-mul...
Those aren't actually spinoffs in the sense of what IBM is doing; "Google" was effectively just renamed "Alphabet", with its core business in a new subunit called "Google". They are all still within the same corporate ownership structure. Its an internal organizational change, not a separation into separately-owned organizations.
A “spin-off” within a common corporate umbrella is a different thing done for different reasons than a corporate divorce kind of spin-off like IBM is doing.
Like: We'll give you an 80% discount in the first quarter, and the discount goes down by 20% per quarter, eventually you'll either be negotiating your contracts with us like any other potential customer, or you'll have moved off to some other platform.
Every holding has transfer pricing [1] as BAU, and I can assume that it is also the case for IBM
Companies split when two halves just have such vastly different objectives and futures that, at an organizational practical sense, it no longer makes sense for the same board/CEO/management to be running them together.
Splitting them up lets both halves select boards/CEOs/management that is best for them, and pursue strategies that are best separately. The "underperforming" segment may now perform better now that it's free to use AWS/Azure/Google cloud tools instead of just IBM's... it can enter into strategic alliances it couldn't before... it can merge with another company that wouldn't have made sense before.
As for the people who work there... they're still employed so nothing really changes day-to-day.
But the main point is that this frees the "worse part", if you still want to call it that, to do what is best for it. It may very well turn out to thrive and be a huge success. It's still a normal business like any other.
If it were truly dead weight it wouldn't be spun off -- it would be shut down and everyone would be laid off. The fact it's being spun off or split means it's expected to be a viable business on its own. Nobody can predict the future -- who knows, it might outperform the cloud part long-term.