It's a pity, because that was those books were my first and only experience of Penrose for many years, and it was only much later that I learned of his much more interesting work in geometry and mathematics, and their use in physics, the study of crystals, etc.
My dismissal of his work on consciousness was based on those grounds. I think my "caricature" was fairly accurate, but if you think different that's fine, if you can elaborate.
The part I forgot above was that I also dismissed it on the basis of math, which is surprising given that Penrose is a greater mathematician than I'll ever be, but his whole reason to evoke "quantum" was that a Newtonian-based brain could not know that a "Gödel sentence" was true, so our brains must be non-Newtonian. It was absurd on the face of it (our brain's belief about statements don't constitute a formal logic), and was also well-criticized by other mathematicians, whose names I'd have to dredge out of my 20-year old essays.
I understand that for someone who appreciates science, but not philosophy, the book turning out as straddling those two fields might be a letdown. But that's not the authors fault since those books are not presented as academic research, but only informed by it.
Infuriating for me are philosophical discussions which don't draw substantially on science.
Can you give us at least an idea of what bits we might be missing?
Because free time is finite. If they read it three times and still decided it verbosely failed to make its case, why not read it two or three times more?
Can you cite a point or two where you think Penrose makes a strong case above and beyond "consciousness and quantum theory are both mysterious and are therefore probably connected?"
The other part is where he describes how quantum physics, logic and consciousness are weird. That's basically just science popularization, coming from a top mind in both math and physics. To me, that's already enough to justify the price of admission: the time and mental effort of going through the book at a pace that assures comprehension, which does take some patience.
Now, I've no-doubt I'm doing the great man a disservice, but it felt like a very thin conclusion for such a fat book.