Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami...
by BlueGh0st on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:19AM
(#24706286)
And no matter how much privilege may have indeed played a part, it seems very gross to me that people seek to debase their achievements by focusing on aspects that these kids can't even control. It's rude (to a point) to point out how much raw luck may have had in one's achievements, but why is privilege (which is arguably very similar in many ways) fair game?
The focus should be on all of the effort that the kid put forth which many other equally privileged or lucky kids would have squandered.
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami...
by rtpg on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:13AM
(#24706496)
I think the point is that the effort is maybe not as much as the lauding implies ("Guy makes WSYWIG editor in 10 seconds" is less impressive if I just use contenteditable)
I don't really agree on this reading for this case, but this _definitely_ applies for basically every 30 under 30 list and lots of stuff in VC-land (Theranos etc). Some people get a silver spoon of a situation and get lauded for basically showing up.
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami...
by m000 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:55AM
(#24706700)
What is irking people is not the achievement, but the meticulous documentation and flagrant promotion of the achievement. Guinness Book of Records didn't invite themselves you know. They also don't come for free. Typically you need to pay a hefty fee to come and document your record AFAIK (another sign of privilege).
More kids may have similar achievements but their parents never sought publicity photo shoots for them. Exposing kids to this kind of publicity may be bad for them down the line. May make them feel like a failure if they aren't able to pull another newsworthy stunt in the future.
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami...
by watwut on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:24AM
(#24706302)
> It's rude (to a point) to point out how much raw luck
Why should it be rude?
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami...
by codeisawesome on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:12AM
(#24706250)
Thank goodness we live after the 2010s then =)
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami...
by DharmaPolice on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:28AM
(#24706314)
Meh, I'm literally a Communist and I find the tone unnecessarily negative at times. Yes, obviously the kid is privileged, but there are a shit load of privileged kids and how many of them are doing cool experiments like this?
Up until around 2010, you'd be shouted down as a troll for taking down this kid's achievements.