The judge who originally made East Texas a haven for patent trolls, T. John Ward, on the other hand, certainly did act improperly. In particular, his son owned a law firm which specialises in representing plaintiffs in his father's court. That firm now employs Ward senior.
https://thepriorart.typepad.com/the_prior_art/2008/03/judge-...
Stare decisis. He can load whatever judicial circuit he's in with patent troll friendly precedent. The only way to undo it is at the appellate or Supreme Court.
If you can't see where the conflict there is, I'm not sure I can make it any clearer. That he actively advertised to attract court traffic to his jurisdiction should be quite alarming. That he's already "telegraphed" his proclivities should be grounds for at a minimum an ethics inquest.
A blatantly prejudiced judge bodes well for no one.
- Owns a stake (or has family who does) in a local patent-focused lawfirm
- Plans to return to private practice after precedent is set and expects precedent to increase income
- Seeks future political influence with people who would benefit from biased opinions on cases
I think you are implying that he will get back into the private sector after having granted some valuable patents to some of his friends, hopefully landing a great consulting gig or job with them? Or just start his own?
To me this is a red herring. What this judge is doing has all kinds of problems regardless of what his motive is. Even if the judge thinks he's doing it for the good of the legal system and won't accept any personal gain at all, he's still wrong and he should be stopped.
[0] https://www.uscourts.gov/judges-judgeships/judicial-compensa...
It seems obvious that this guy is corrupt, but exactly how? Presumably the federal government doesnt pay per case. Does he have an interest in a local law firm? Does he get kickbacks in cash? Or is he planning on returning to practicing law in a few years through the revolving door and this will raise his profile?
I guess we shouldn't rule out the possibility that he just feels passionately about patent law and shaping the American legal landscape to his own opinions. The late Justice Ginsberg was widely praised for the same. But somehow it's harder to believe in this field.