Why? Where does this logic come from? And apparently it's common, because PureDarwin mentioned in another comment does just that for some reason.
IMO, the right thing to do would be to replicate Apple's proprietary stack as closely as possible. Like, literally take the real macOS and start replacing essential proprietary frameworks like Cocoa and Quartz and core apps like Finder and Dock with fully API-compatible open-source ones. You'll eventually end up with a fully open-source operating system capable of running macOS apps.
There's also some hairiness legally about working from within the official Mac OS system outwards AFAIK.
That's the point. ReactOS doesn't use any of the Linux parts, and it's reimplementing everything from scratch because there are no open-source components in Windows afaik.
That said at this point I don't see anything inherently easier or beneficial about this than creating some other project around an alternative paradigm than PC derived desktop systems on top of some existing better supported kernel.
That said contrary to what the previous poster implied I don't think either OpenDarwin or PureDarwin aimed at reproducing the proprietary bits—they were/are essentially quirky, buggy, poorly documented BSDs just as reliant on the floss ecosystem as much better supported stacks.