News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by jessriedel on Saturday October 03, 2020 @09:16AM (#24671855)
This is the millionth article on lunar far-side telescopes I've seen that conveniently fails to explain why you'd want to place a radio telescope on the surface rather than just at the Earth-Moon L2 Lagrange point (i.e., the point on the far side of the Moon that orbits with the Moon around the Earth and keeps the Moon between itself and the Earth). I'm sick of not having this obvious question answered, so I dug into it.

Like the lunar surface, a telescope at L2 keeps the Moon permanently between itself and the Earth to block incoming radio waves. For a fixed telescope size, going down into the Moon's gravity well increases costs tremendously. And, although doing construction in a vacuum is never easy, it's a lot easier when you're in zero-g and you don't need a crane! Unlike the far-side surface, L2 has exposure to sunlight for power for ~90% of the time. (You would still need a relay satellite in a different lunar orbit for communications, of course, just like the far-side surface.)

As far as I can tell from browsing the article

https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.12689

and the much more helpful analysis of the lunar radio environment that they cite

https://sci-hub.st/https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/pdf/10.2514/6.IA...

the only benefits to going to to the surface is (1) you get better shielding of the extremely low frequencies (≲ 1 kHz) which are long enough wavelength to diffract around the Earth, but don't think those are detectable unless you have a telescope that's many kilometers in size. (2) you avoid radio signals from satellites in geostationary orbits, but these should be very small since the transmitters are pointing toward the Earth.

Indeed, the faculty member who is advising the undergraduate intern lead author says

> “The first SETI observations that are done from the lunar farside will be done from orbit, there’s no question about that,” says Andrew Siemion, the director of the Berkeley SETI Research Center and the second author on the paper. “I think eventually we absolutely want to do something on the surface because we want to build a very large aperture telescope, but even when we’re at that point I don’t think that would negate the utility of doing things from orbit as well.”

and I think he's downplaying how tremendously costly going to the surface would be for very little benefit.

EDIT: Note that the FARSIDE array on the surface they mention is much better justified, but it's not SETI, it's an array, the surface benefits from solar storm shielding, and it probably only makes sense because it piggybacks on high bandwidth connection for the NASA Lunar Gateway. More details here:

https://www.lpi.usra.edu/leag/white-papers-astronomy/FARSIDE...

https://twitter.com/di_goldene_pave/status/13123915724079554...

Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by jvanderbot on Saturday October 03, 2020 @11:38AM (#24672712)
From this study: https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2020_Phase_...

The sun is cited as a significant source of noise that can be shielded by the lunar body.

Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by jessriedel on Saturday October 03, 2020 @11:58AM (#24672846)
Yes, thanks! That's mentioned in my edit (although it should just be "solar wind" rather than "solar storm") and the twitter thread I link. Note that that's only a particular (though valuable) frequency range, and that it's still unclear to me whether it's cheaper to go down to the lunar surface rather than just build a 10 times larger telescope at L2.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 03, 2020 @01:59PM (#24673623)
> And, although doing construction in a vacuum is never easy, it's a lot easier when you're in zero-g and you don't need a crane!

That's not exactly true just yet!

All our construction knowhow is based on thousands of years of building things on Earth's surface, under a constant 1G force pulling everything in a single direction, as well as a landmass to brace against. Every technique we have has these conditions baked in as assumptions; we exploit them all the time, without even thinking about it. Like, e.g. if you put some mortar on a brick, and then a brick on top of that, you're relying on gravity to supply the pressure that makes the two bricks strongly bound.

Meanwhile - AFAIK - we have zero experience in constructing anything in 0G, beyond assembling some large prefabs. The closest we come to microgravity construction is whatever it is that underwater welders do, but that's still not the same.

With this in mind, it may be that for now, building installations on Moon's surface will be easier than constructing them in space.

Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by jessriedel on Saturday October 03, 2020 @03:15PM (#24674053)
I think your overall point is wrong, but it would be a large discusssion. So I'll just concentrate on this: a telescope on the moon or at L2 will, in fact, be large pre-fab. Indeed, we have zero experience building anything in a vacuum in gravity, but we have decades of experience assembling pre-fab structures in zero gravity vacuum. That's what will be easiest.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by hutzlibu on Saturday October 03, 2020 @04:53PM (#24674591)
His overall point was that we have only experience constructing in g and allmost zero experience constructing in zero g.

And that seems very true to me.

Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by jessriedel on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:33AM (#24678178)
I know that was his point. I acknowledged that although I think his overall point was very wrong I wasn't going to debate it because it would be a sprawling discussion.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by manfredo on Saturday October 03, 2020 @04:59PM (#24674627)
> Meanwhile - AFAIK - we have zero experience in constructing anything in 0G, beyond assembling some large prefabs.

Weren't the ISS and Mir constructed in zero G? Well, in free fall but that's still zero gravity in effect.

Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 03, 2020 @05:19PM (#24674747)
That's just assembling large prefabs, though, which I explicitly excluded from my "zero experience" observation.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by manfredo on Saturday October 03, 2020 @05:32PM (#24674814)
Wouldn't construction of an orbital observatory consist of putting together prefabs? Not to mention, modern construction often does consist of putting together prefabricated pieces so saying we have no experience with construction in zero G only putting together prefabricated components is somewhat contradictory.
Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 03, 2020 @05:47PM (#24674910)
That depends if that was what the original comment meant.

But still, I fail to see how attaching prefabs in 0G is going to be easier than doing it in 1G, or even 0.166G. It's nice to have a well-defined "down" direction and a landmass to brace against. You don't need station keeping and magic trickery to keep angular momentum in check.

The main difficulty I'd see with assembling prefabs on the Moon would be landing them.

Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by koheripbal on Saturday October 03, 2020 @09:19AM (#24671879)
The article literally says that a satellite in orbit is likely the first step.

Also, the further you are from the moon - the worse the shielding.

Re:The case for building a SETI observatory on the moon by jessriedel on Saturday October 03, 2020 @09:28AM (#24671957)
First, the orbital option described in the article is not L2 but rather a low lunar orbit which spends only a small fraction of it's time in the lunar shadow.

Second, in my comment I literally quote the "first step" claim and explain why it's an extreme understatement, in particular because the shielding is not worse except for undetectable wavelengths and sources not actually pointed at the telescope. It's like saying we should we should build transparent houses so we get more vitamin D but of course as a first step we should go outside or take a multivitamin.