You would be ok with different tax rates for different size corporations?
A committee / agency to decide what is or is not an oligopoly? So, someone coming up with a new app that does something never done before, that would be a monopoly or oligopoly, right?
Markets have to be overseen by the state to some degree, because free markets rely on certain conditions being met in order to work optimally. One of these conditions is that the companies in the market must be competing.
> You would be ok with different tax rates for different size corporations?
You mean like how individuals are taxed at different rates dependent on the size of their income?
> A committee / agency to decide what is or is not an oligopoly?
We already have that: the court system. I'm not describing anything new here. Competition law in the US dates back at least to the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890.
> So, someone coming up with a new app that does something never done before, that would be a monopoly or oligopoly, right?
Having a monopoly by itself is fine; you just can't leverage that monopoly to artificially inhibit competition.
The role of courts is not of fact finder, market minder, or regulator. You should educate yourself on that topic before proposing stuff like this.
You would have to create an IRS-like body to determine the monopolistic status of every market, industry, company. And tell me, are you just concerned about big tech companies making 30%, or would you regulate grocery chains that make 4% just the same?
It's like people don't think of the details and implications of an idea before proposing that they've got the answer.
Then what do you call United States v. AT&T? Or United States v. Microsoft Corporation?
> The role of courts is not of fact finder, market minder, or regulator.
It's certainly the courts' job to enforce anti-trust legislation.
> You would have to create an IRS-like body to determine the monopolistic status of every market, industry, company.
You mean like the FTC?
But again, it's not whether a company is a monopoly; it's whether they're engaged in anti-competititive practices to maintain that monopoly. The FTC and the Antitrust division of the DoJ investigate antitrust violations, not so-called "innocent" monopolies.
> And tell me, are you just concerned about big tech companies making 30%, or would you regulate grocery chains that make 4% just the same?
It doesn't matter how much profit a company makes, or how much it charges; it's whether or not it's artificially reducing competition in order to keep prices high. There's typically less barriers to entry to selling groceries, but its certainly not impossible for a grocery chain to engage in anticompetitive practices.
> It's like people don't think of the details and implications of an idea before proposing that they've got the answer.
You seem to be under the impression this is an idea I'm proposing, but what I'm describing is how competition law has worked for the last century.
Companies working to create bottlenecks in society instead of removing them really is bad for everyone, so governments needs to step in to fix that.
https://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/economy-budget/26214...
This is called our court system. And they have been handling anti-trust law for a century now. And they have done a pretty reasonable job of it.
Anti-trust law is not something new. It is well established.
You think that's what the courts are supposed to do? You have a serious flaw in understanding what courts are for if so.
No I am not! I am calling for the existing law, known as the Sherman Anti-trust act, to be enforced in the same way that it has been enforce for literally a century!
There are already laws that cover this! They have been around for literally 100 years. And our existing court system is more than capable of enforcing our existing laws, in the same way that they have been doing, for a literal century.
> You think that's what the courts are supposed to do?
Courts have already enforced the sherman anti-trust act, and have been enforcing it for 100 years. And they will continue to enforce it when violations come up.
> by the status and concentration of its market
I recommend that you go research anti-trust law, and how it is enforced.
The courts already use the "concentration of the market", in existing anti-trust law evaluations. They have been doing this for a century! It is entirely standard, in basically every single anti-trust evaluation, that has ever happened, to look at how concentrated the market is.
Absolutely. There is a cost to society when business is concentrated in a few large organisations. It descreases competition (which forms the bedrock of the capitalist system), and concentrates wealth (extracting it from local communities). It seems completely fair to make theae comapnies pay for that cost. If it means that they can't compete and get outcompeted by smaller companies then... good.
That falls under competition law. It's in a government's interests to encourage companies to compete with each other, and to prevent a single or a handful of companies explicitly or implicitly agreeing to control market pricing to the detriment of consumers.
In this case, both Google and Apple set the same 30% pricing, and clearly neither have any incentive to rock the boat and compete with each other, and every incentive to dissuade or prevent other companies from creating competing app stores. When competition in a market fails, it's up to the courts or government to step in.
"I find irony in many people who get probably so knee-jerk opposed to Google/Apple and "on Epic's side" will find themselves justifying why they should be free to set their own prices when they launch their next product."
Its not hypocritical (or even ironic) to say that there should be different rules for companies operating as part of an oligopoly, compared to small business competing in a crowded marketplace.