When you have a natural monopoly operating key public infrastructure, regulation is a clear and justifiable option.
The iOS and Google platforms have barely existed more than a decade, and the platforms + app ecosystem are constantly evolving. New platforms and app ecosystems are emerging too, with Facebook/Oculus, Valve/Steam, Amazon with Fire/Alexa, etc.
Enshrining today’s dominant app ecosystems as the government sanctioned ones will surely stifle their evolution and innovation, because that’s what declaring something a utility does: assumes there is no differentiation, so slow government regs / bureaucracy can control it.
I don’t believe Apple and iOS are the end of history of ecosystems. Atari wasn’t, Microsoft wasn’t, IBM wasn’t.
"Go ahead, propose that every company only be allowed a 5% markup on its costs. Let's see where that takes us."
In the case of Android, it takes us back to when Google previously had a 5% cut. They've done it before they can do it again.
An app store that sells games and voluntary entertainments is not a public infrastructure, operated in the public interest. That's almost laughable.
And don't be so quick to conclude that now because you reap the benefits of a system that was previously set up, you can simply decide that you think the % is too high and take it back "in the public interest". Go ahead, propose that every company only be allowed a 5% markup on its costs. Let's see where that takes us.