I have also seen this sort of behavior fist hand when a team I worked with insisted I destroy the t-shirts for an event instead of donating them to a charity since it would negatively impact the brand :/
I don't think it applies in this case.
Despite its marketing, Apple very much is a mass market company and you can't really both be mass market and luxury. Also, there are already plenty of second hand iPhones on the market. So much that I seriously doubt it is supply constrained.
If I had to guess, it's probably more about avoiding competition in the SE segment than protecting the brand.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Harkin_(podcaster)
Edit: or not, seems there is another author sharing same name http://www.jamesharkin.co.uk/about/
Sending 100k usable devices to recycling is an absolute waste of resources. It's immoral and in contradiction with Apple's environmental commitment.
In my opinion (and I see many sharing the sentiment here) if apple are gonna send perfectly usable devices for recycling instead of reselling them, then that is bad.
Hence I would argue that their right to have a contract upheld weighs lower here than literally everyone else's right on the planet to not waste resources.
We have many things you simply are not allowed into contracts. High interest loans, organ sales, you name it. Forcing someone to destroy a usable device, polluting the environment and using up resources as a result just might become one of those. I'd be in favor actually. I don't value apple's stock more than the planet. But then I also don't own any of it, so there's that...
Not only because of the environmental impact but also because this is a way for Apple to control the market.