News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by ctide on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @01:50AM (#2465418)
Since when is $200 an outrageous amount of money for a seriously significant performance increase?
Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by shin_lao on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:03AM (#2465446)
It's more than $ 200. It's more around $ 300 per computer and in a laptop it's an incredible amount of money ($800+ if I'm correct) if you have a Sony or an Apple one.

Additionally the performance increase is important, but doesn't matter for everything network related.

In other words I'd say it's almost worth what you pay for it.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by ctide on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:09AM (#2465458)
I installed one in my Macbook Pro a few weeks ago for ~$300, but bought the 120 GB SSD vs. 80 GB. Considering I'm only using 60GB of it, I certainly could have bought the 80 GB and had everything shipped for right around $200.

It's easily the most noticeable upgrade I've ever done.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by catch23 on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:15AM (#2465474)
Actually it's around $200 for a 100gig drive: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820227...

But you can always have more than 1 hard drive. Buy a 500gig one for all your large file content and use the smaller one for the OS. Pretty much all SSDs come in laptop drive format so I don't know where this $800 number is coming from. They might have been $800 last year, but transistor prices drop pretty fast.

I have 2 drives in my macbook pro -- 120gig vertex 2 ssd, and a 500gig samsung "old style" hard drive.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by silencio on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:14AM (#2465468)
It is $200 or so for a decent 2.5" 128gb SSD that you can install into a laptop or a desktop (see http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE...).

The only real problem with that solution is that 128gb isn't enough for some people, but it is not difficult to offload the data to another storage device, either internally or externally. I've been keeping under 128gb on my main laptops (MacBook Pro and Air) for a year and a half now (when I first switched over to using SSDs) without a problem.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by rodh257 on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:11AM (#2465461)
A vertex 2 is around $200 from what I can see: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820227...

If you buy a sony or apple laptop, replace the drive yourself. I just bought a 13" MBP and bought a $25 caddy to put my Vertex 2 in the DVD bay. That way I have Windows 7 booting from that SSD, OSX on the normal HDD with extra storage available there. Of course you could just replace the HDD with an SSD and not void your warranty.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by shin_lao on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @07:19AM (#2466126)
Wouldn't that void the warranty?
Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by rodh257 on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @09:31AM (#2466509)
replacing the HDD with an SSD doesn't void the warranty, however replacing the DVD drive with one (like I did) does.
Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by acqq on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:05AM (#2465453)
Since when it's a "serious" performance increase when "it boots faster"? Or if the first grep after the boot is faster (others must be fast since the file cache kicks in for every next one, unless you have, say, 128 MB RAM). Really not worth to mention.
Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by ctide on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:15AM (#2465470)
Every application I launch, launches in a fraction of the time. I don't like to leave every application I use (some of which are horrendous memory hogs, such as Illustrator and Photoshop) running perpetually, so having next to no load time is an amazing benefit.

Textmate is another excellent example. Search in project is completely usable with an SSD. I had temporarily switched to AckMate because of how unbearably this feature was, now it's instant again.

Booting faster is the least of my cares as my laptop is only rebooted when updates force me to.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by mpakes on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:14AM (#2465467)
Spoken like someone who has never used a machine with an SSD. My SSD is by far the best performance investment I've made in recent years.

A fast CPU is worthless if you're burning 30% of your cycles waiting for the HDD to deliver your data. Relying on file cache is not good enough.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by jonah on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:47AM (#2465557)
I just upgraded my MBP and opted for the slowest 2.0 Ghz CPU and spent the savings on 8Gb RAM and a Vertex 3. Absolutely worth it.

Just to give a rough idea - 4k random writes:

  Vertex 3 - 214 MB/s
  WD VelociRaptor - 1.9 MB/s
http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph4256/36481.png
Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by rodh257 on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:13AM (#2465465)
Applications start faster, loading any files from disk start faster. It depends on your usage scenario, but for .NET development in Windows I can vouch for it's value.

$200 for an SSD is a far better use of money for the average programmer than say the upgrade from I5 to I7 on a 13" MBP. There are many parts of your computer which you'd spend $200 on that get you less of a general every day performance boost than a SSD.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by masklinn on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:25AM (#2465502)
> It depends on your usage scenario, but for .NET development in Windows I can vouch for it's value.

The reality is that it significantly increases performances for all workloads but streaming videos (huge sequential reads).

Most of computer usage is random access to small files, and that's a field where SSDs utterly annihilate rotating platters (not that rotas have any advantage but storage capacity, mind you, SSDs are also superior in seq read and write, but on random we're talking 2MB/s on 4k random write for a VelociRaptor to >200MB/s for a Vertex 3; 0.68MB 4k random read for a VR to >90MB for a Vertex 3, for sequential performances the difference will be a factor of 2 or 3 tops between a VR and a top-of-the-line SSD)

The difference is, of course, even more impressive for laptop drives: most laptops don't house 10k, 10W monsters like the VRs

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by stewbrew on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:37AM (#2465532)
So we have people who upgraded their hard disk to a ssd and say it resulted in a "serious performance increase" and we have people who still use traditional hard disks (why on earth would somebody want to do something like that?) who say it isn't. Maybe the judgment is based on experience?
Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by robgough on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @05:23AM (#2465900)
I wonder if the non-owners think that it's merely a case of those who did buy one trying to justify their purchase.

Those of us with one know that really isn't the case, but of course it's hard to convince someone to spend that much money on something they don't think will make a difference.

Since I put one in my late-2008 MBP at Christmas, I've not seen a single beach ball. Best upgrade ever.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by bradleyland on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @09:46AM (#2466552)
I was such a huge skeptic prior to upgrading. I was in the "why should I care about boot times; I never reboot" camp. Then I started thinking about whether or not I could use fast application boot times, but I rationalized that away with 4 GB of RAM and the fact that I pretty much leave all my important apps running all the time.

Then the Crucial RealSSD C300 (256 GB) went on sale prior to xmas 2010, and my girlfriend ordered one for me surreptitiously, after overhearing conversations between me and a friend about SSD performance.

As it turns out, I was completely wrong to be skeptical. The differences should have been crystal clear to me. Think of the difference between using your iPhone/iPad/Android and your computer. Notice how everything on your phone occurs nearly instantly. Most of us don't even consider it, because these devices never came with slow magnetic platter drives. Even with minimal (by desktop standards) RAM and absolutely anemic CPU power, these devices manage a level of responsiveness that makes them disappear in to the background as we use the software. An SSD brings this experience to your desktop. The performance difference is present in everything that you do, not just launching applications.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by masklinn on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @05:49AM (#2465948)
> I wonder if the non-owners think that it's merely a case of those who did buy one trying to justify their purchase.

Either that, or a case of blub.

SSDs are one of those pieces of hardware closest to magic you can find, the differences between HDD and (modern) SSD are so big it's hard to understand them until you've experienced them. I know I didn't before I got mine, but Anand's writing on the subject convinced me there was something to it (anand being a person whose opinion I respect greatly, and one of those who dived early into understanding SSDs, he didn't hesitate crucifying early crappy SSD, and his SSD series are fantastic in their breadth and depth)

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by catch23 on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:18AM (#2465485)
Try doing a fgrep in 500 files. It's almost 20 times faster than my hard disk. I think it's funny how all these people spend money on a faster cpu when they could really just use a faster disk.
Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by beedogs on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:41AM (#2465545)
Uh, how is it NOT a performance increase? Applications load faster. Everything loads faster. The OS boots faster.

What a horrible argument.

Re:Why are you not using a SSD yet? by tlrobinson on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @03:55AM (#2465714)
It's not just booting/launching apps, everything feels snappier.