News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by nickthemagicman on Thursday October 01, 2020 @09:27AM (#24650554)
So much focus is on the 'nurture' aspect for reasons why women leave tech or don't thrive in tech.

Why can't the 'nature' aspect also be a factor?

Women have fundamentally different biological imperatives than men.

Now days with ample choice in careers and women gaining the lions share of college degrees....they still choose certain subjects.

Are there just certain characteristics of different fields that attract different types of people?

Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by helen___keller on Thursday October 01, 2020 @10:20AM (#24651097)
I'll play ball. I assume the reason for the focus is because we can change the 'nurture' part and we can't change the 'nature' part.

I mean the standard argument that follows from your post would be that we shouldn't aim for 50% male 50% female because maybe in truth there are just 30% less women "naturally inclined" to taking up engineering than there are men.

I can accept that maybe we shouldn't target a particular quota or ratio on diversity. But I don't accept that we should drop inclusivity and diversity altogether: regardless of the 'nature' aspect, if we KNOW that there are issues with the 'nurture' aspect then we should do something about that.

So then we return to the question: Are there issues with our culture where it isn't inclusive enough, and if so what can we do to remedy this? And that's something that I believe every HR department should be asking if they care about employee well-being.

Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by nickthemagicman on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:23PM (#24652787)
Ok I'll bite also....

Your theory is that HR should take actions to social engineer a culture to accomodate women.

I propose that any attempts to social engineer a culture via HR or any non-organic method is a doomed enterprise from the start.

You also will have to social engineer a culture that fits other groups.

What about older developers? What about different race developers? What about cross-gender developers? What about Ahmish developers who only use pen and paper? What about Indian culture vs Korean culture vs Chinese culture vs American culture?

It rapidly becomes a slippery slope of accommodating each and every cultural difference.

Then you have side effects. Also, after these HR corrections, what if workplace culture becomes so biased towards one group such that other groups are excluded?

The emphasis on 'culture fit' is itself an exclusionary idea by nature as it implies that there is a pre-set culture to fit into instead of the culture emerging organically from the employees.

Basic, minimum work provided culture does not need to be inclusive it needs to be tolerant and fair, and that is all.

The goal is not inclusivity towards any one group, the goal is a to award performance based on hard work, talent, productivity, etc.

Engineering a culture is a ridiculous and to be frank, creepy idea. and is a fruitless doomed endeavor.

Instead of HR focusing on a more inclusive culture they need to be focusing on objective empirical ways to measure employee value and the culture issue will sort itself out.

Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by helen___keller on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:19PM (#24653593)
> I propose that any attempts to social engineer a culture via HR or any non-organic method is a doomed enterprise from the start.

Maybe this argument has merit, but it's worth noting that HR frequently does this anyways completely outside the scope of diversity & inclusion. Other core values that HR tries to "engineer" are often things like "obsessed with product" or "only cares about the customer" or some equally fake-sounding corporate nonsense.

Nonetheless, HR tries to engineer corporate cultures, both relating to and not relating to diversity & inclusiveness. I would assume there is some evidence of success by the fact that nearly every corporation does this, but maybe not. I think that's hardly an attack against D&I though, that's an attack on the existence of HR in the first place!

> You also will have to social engineer a culture that fits other groups.

> What about older developers? What about different race developers? What about cross-gender developers? What about Ahmish developers who only use pen and paper? What about Indian culture vs Korean culture vs Chinese culture vs American culture?

> It rapidly becomes a slippery slope of accommodating each and every cultural difference.

I don't think that's a slippery slope or even that difficult. If someone has a requirement for their culture that doesn't impede work, we SHOULD accommodate that: yes, we should have vegetarian options at the company lunches. Yes, we should be okay with Jewish coworkers taking off Yom Kippur. Yes, we should be okay with cross-gender developers using the pronoun of their choice. The Amish one is less likely because that affects business output so I'm sure HR departments can find an excuse to not accommodate that one, but in theory if an Amish pen/paper dev could do high quality work then I don't see why not.

> what if workplace culture becomes so biased towards one group such that other groups are excluded?

I mean, this is literally the status quo right? The whole reason for this so-called "social engineering" is because the status quo workplace culture IS biased towards one group, so the goal is to make it less biased towards them. Maybe in the process it "backfires" and makes it biased against that group, but if it does so in a significant way then I would argue we'd need D&I to help the former majority group.

Either way, the difficulty in this process isn't a convincing argument to not even try.

> The emphasis on 'culture fit' is itself an exclusionary idea by nature as it implies that there is a pre-set culture to fit into instead of the culture emerging organically from the employees.

I'm not sure what to say about this except (a) The term 'culture fit' is from my experience not related to D&I but rather used as an excuse to fire or not hire based on team members with power who don't like you (b) As a corollary to (a), most actions resulting from 'culture fit' are in fact the result of employee's opinions, and thus "organic" culture. I've never seen someone not get hired because the team members really liked the interviewee, but the interviewee didn't display enough enthusiasm for the customer and that's a core value. (as an example of an inorganic culture fit)

> The goal is not inclusivity towards any one group, the goal is a to award performance based on hard work, talent, productivity, etc.

What you're describing is a culture of meritocracy. That's nice, until you lose a dozen great-devs when the brilliant-dev (who can't get fired because he's brilliant) is an absolute asshole to everyone else on the team and makes their life miserable.

Basically, my response to you is that you clearly prefer a purely meritocratic culture, and while I don't think that's an unreasonable preference, I think the consensus among decision makers at large corporations is that a purely meritocratic culture is not effective, certainly not to the degree that you think "the culture issue will sort itself out".

Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:27PM (#24653701)
> Nonetheless, HR tries to engineer corporate cultures, both relating to and not relating to diversity & inclusiveness.

I think that's far less true than it superficially appears. I think HR tries to create a PR image of interest in exactly the things that would, if perceived to be absent, motivate lawsuits against the company, for the precise purpose of being seen by the "human resources" they manage as allies to come to in the case of the problem, rather than the opponent they generally, in fact, are.

HR is far less likely to be trying to engineer an inclusive culture as to be trying to create an image of the HR organization itself that makes those who feel excluded come to them to the mollified (and to give HR a chance to work with management to weave a defenseive narrative) before seeking outside counsel.

Now, this does have some effect on culture, because you can't effectively maintain this kind of image without actually doing something about the most highly-visible and flagrant systematic violations, whether its something substantive or at least finding a way to reduce their visibility and the air of casual acceptance around them.

Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday October 01, 2020 @10:06AM (#24650909)
It is nature: despite of all efforts men still cannot get pregnant.

The society is trying hard to fight the nature and convince women that their primary goal should be a successful career, but so far the nature wins.

Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by Kednicma on Thursday October 01, 2020 @09:36AM (#24650633)
Mostly, because we know that there were eras when women dominated programming, typing, debugging, documentation, etc. So we know that there's no biological or innate reason why women are unable/unwilling/unskilled at this labor. Instead, we conclude that it's culture.

Incidentally, part of the culture which causes women to leave is your inherently-othering comment which seeks to divide women and men into a binary categorization.

Edit to the children comments: To spell it out more clearly: The proportion of laborers in different fields is wholly cultural. The entire concept of fields of labor is wholly cultural. The entire concept of labor as something done not just for survival is cultural. Your brains are extremely plastic and you exist almost entirely on cultural, not instinctual, impulses.

Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by thursday0987 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @09:55AM (#24650811)
> Mostly, because we know that there were eras when women dominated programming, typing, debugging, documentation, etc.

wasn't this the same era that women were mostly secretaries and programming, typing, debugging, doucmentation, etc. were all seen as secondary tasks supporting the main effort instead of the main effort itself?

also, during these eras, there simply weren't nearly as many programmers or money in programming, so the segment of the population that even had access to a computer, let alone knew how to program, was severly limited and not a representative sample of the potential population of programmers at that time.

> So we know that there's no biological or innate reason why women are unable/unwilling/unskilled at this labor.

we know no such thing and its bad science to say that we do. Perhaps you should qualify this statement to be more clear.

> Instead, we conclude that it's culture.

bad conclusion that ignores other factors, including availability of access to computers, proportion of the population that knows how to program, status of programming in relation to the work being done (secretary work vs primary work), etc.

Re:Half of young women will leave their tech job by age 35, ... by nickthemagicman on Thursday October 01, 2020 @09:49AM (#24650768)
Those eras where women had very little choice of other careers except clerical positions of which programming was an extension of at the time.

Well aren't they? There's quite a lot of differences between men and women whether one wants to accept it or not. There's massive amounts of socioligical and physiological science backing this.

Additionally, you can Google sociological studies on what women and men prioritize in their careers and women overwhelming prefer caregiving and time for family while men prefer more traditional status and materialistic success.

Google it!

Step out of the critical sex theory for a second. This isn't some toxic masculinity seeking to repress women. This is reality.