Re:Car seats as contraception
by etothepii on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:22AM
(#24648294)
Didn't Levitt and Dubner establish that a standard seatbelt would be safe enough to class as a car seat for children over 2 if they weren't explicitly banned by law.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Would you mind linking that if you have it around somewhere? It seems quite doubtful that a seatbelt would work on someone who isn’t even tall enough for the sash to go over their torso…
Here’s the paper:
https://pricetheory.uchicago.edu/levitt/Papers/doyle-levitt%...
And here’s a pretty entertaining TED talk he gave:
Someone let the airlines know.
Re:Car seats as contraception
by _-___________-_ on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:07AM
(#24648943)
Airline seatbelts are designed to restrain you from flying out of your seat in turbulence. They will do little to restrain your head from hitting the seat in front in a front-on impact, and have a good chance of causing injuries in any kind of impact. For that reason, if an impact is considered more likely than usual, you will be instructed to assume the brace position. (Note also that crew have proper harnesses.)
But those are lap belts, and also planes tend to have different issues than cars do.
if you're riding planes that are at risk of >50kph impacts, you should probably move to a different airline
Re:Car seats as contraception
by goodcanadian on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:37AM
(#24648399)
IIRC, what they claimed is that there was no statistically significant evidence that car seats for children over two (i.e. not infants) saved lives.
I recall when I was young (before car seat laws), the car had shorter seat belts in the back. Almost as though they expected children to sit there . . .
When you were young back seats has lap belts but not shoulder straps.
Re:Car seats as contraception
by goodcanadian on Thursday October 01, 2020 @10:19AM
(#24651090)
That is true of the first car I remember, but the second had (child-sized) shoulder belts.
I believe so. The single largest factor in survivability at any age is just being in the back seat, ie further Way from the impact.