News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by samatman on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:33PM (#24634301)
It's a good contribution to the conversation, keeping in mind that Adm. Rickover wrote these words in 1953.

Anyone could have said similar things about computers in 1953, and been just as correct.

Are nuclear reactors computers? Of course not, and neither have practical reactors kept pace in development with practical computers.

But neither is it inevitable that steady progress cannot grind down the latter set of characteristics into the former. Indeed, that's what I would bet on, and I think the Admiral would be disappointed in the progress we have(n't) made.

Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by wwweston on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:28PM (#24634621)
> Anyone could have said similar things about computers in 1953, and been just as correct.

Many people could say similar things about software in 2020 and be just as correct. :) The good Admiral may be describing some timeless aspects of engineering, possibly related to the recently discussed observation that reality has a surprising amount of detail: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16184255 .

Though, as you say, over time engineering can grind out some of the practical into practice.

Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by giblfiz on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @08:26PM (#24645834)
I, for one, never have corrosion problems on my software projects.
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by wwweston on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:03PM (#24656121)
You jest, but... compatibility is the corrosion of software. The environment and dependencies underlying your software are slowly oxidizing/transforming all the time and unless you pick only the stainless steel of interfaces/system calls, your software will cease to function more quickly than lots of iron objects rust through.
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by solstice on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:12PM (#24646925)
I take it you're not programming in Rust? /s
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by 317070 on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @08:10AM (#24637912)
In fusion, they can actually pinpoint exactly why it did not pan out as expected since 1953.

For fusion, you need to achieve a high temperature. So "thermal insulation" of the centre of the plasma from the edge of the plasma is really important. The nice thing is, that since charged particles move along magnetic field lines, and magnetic field lines never cross each other, the thermal insulation of plasma made from charged particles is enormous. That would imply it is really easy to achieve really high temperatures.

However, in 1953 they overestimated the enormous "thermal insulation" at higher temperatures by 10 orders of magnitude. That is a ratio of 1e10 between the expected and the actual value. It is still enormous, mind you, but not that enormous.

If that estimation had been correct, we would have had fusion by 1973. However, in that period it gradually became clear that fusion that way was not going to happen as people found lower and lower thermal insulations in their plasmas.

The same thing might have happened with semiconductors. What if the thermal noise were off by 10 orders of magnitude at smaller scales, compared to what was expected in 1953? Computing would not be where it is today, although it would definitely still be a good possibility if we were only pushing harder in circumventing the noise.

Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by taneq on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:47PM (#24635234)
Ah, back in 1953, when they were only 20 years away from practical nuclear fusion.
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by el_oni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @09:29AM (#24638500)
As opposed to 2020 where we're now only about 20 years away from practical nuclear fusion
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by taneq on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @09:00PM (#24646068)
Or 2050 when we will hopefully only be about 20 years away from practical nuclear fusion... ;)
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:14AM (#24636877)
Similar things can be said about computers: the Mill CPU is simple, small, cheap, fast etc and of course can't actually be bought right now.

Vaporware is a real problem in every discipline.

Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by sheeshkebab on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:14PM (#24635116)
I guess we can ask Huawei about how easy it is to build computers in 2020...
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by frequentnapper on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @01:58AM (#24636059)
with stolen blueprints and unlimited govt resources, easy as pie...
Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ... by barry-cotter on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @02:07AM (#24636105)
Not really. After the collapse of the Soviet Union China bought complete blue prints, working models and the time of engineers who had designed Soviet combat aircraft and I believe other military hardware. They still couldn’t replicate them. A tool chain and manufacturing ecosystem is a unit. Industrial espionage is useful but it’s not a way to leap frog 20 steps, maybe four, ten if you’re both lucky and good.