Yes. Cloudflare is both a middlebox service and a certificate authority that can issue itself an SSL cert for any web site. What could possibly go wrong?
Take a look at the certificate for https://ycombinator.com
It's issued by Cloudflare to Cloudflare for the domains "*.ycombinator.com", with an organization of "Cloudflare, Inc."
Oh, and Cloudflare is also a DNS service and a domain registrar. They really do have the power to take over any domain at any time.
It's their web.
They still have the best performing and most feature-ful CDN available. The competition is not even that close. Fastly is the only other CDN I could really consider, but their featureset just doesn't compare.
I don't think thats true. Do you have an actual reference for this? I've used CLoudFlare heavily, along with Akamai, Fastly, Verizon, Bunny, etc.
I would say CloudFlare is the most approachable CDN with a wide set of easily accessible features. Its free tier is terrific too. I would argue that feature for feature, CDN's like Akamai have a much larger feature set, and are also far more complex to deploy.
The CDN space is rife with healthy competition all around, especially with 5G around the corner, but sure, Cloudflare seems to move the quickest and probably has the strongest product vision that resonates with news.yc crowd, a lot. Nothing inherently good or bad about that: In fact, I seem to enjoy using their products as a developer more than other Cloud vendors.
GCP offers free protection for web properties falling under select categories through Jigsaw's Shield program: https://projectshield.withgoogle.com/
AWS does offer freemium DDoS protection with some of their products, like Global Accelerator: https://aws.amazon.com/global-accelerator/features/
Cloudflare isn’t even a viable cloudflare. They lost 100 million dollars last year.
If you go along with the above premise, I don't see what the problem is. You will always have the option of switching CDNs if Cloudflare starts snooping in on user data.
Of course, if you disagree and think CF will take 100% of the market, then what you said makes sense. Personally, I don't see that happening.
IMO cloudflare represents the death of the small player on the public internet, before it most small players ran their own internet-facing services, with it many choose to just run behind cloudflare.
They may not have the bandwidth as you point out, but they have a pretty big chunk of websites. (Obv not 100%)
(That said, AWS has a lot more than “just” the TLS connection on a large fraction of the web, including all of my web properties, so yeah, who are you going to trust and for how long?)
We specifically aren’t interested in pure bit delivery. It’s a commodity business that will have its margins squeezed to zero over time. We provide CDN services because caching is a useful tool in computer science when you want to deliver performance for other applications. If you measured our revenue per bit delivered, it would be far more attractive than any of the traditional CDN providers because we aren’t primarily selling bit delivery where they primarily are.
And you don't really have the option of switching CDNs (at least, not easily) if you've bought into all their proprietary stuff like their workers implementation, various optimization techniques that your site couldn't survive without, etc.
If you give this large a chunk of web traffic to a company, then let them also decrypt everyone's TLS traffic, I can't see that ending well.
Transparency disclaimer: I briefly worked for them and was very uncomfortable with the work they were doing the whole time.