Re:Judge temporarily blocks U.S. ban on TikTok downloads fro...
by freeone3000 on Monday September 28, 2020 @03:40PM
(#24620467)
The executive powers do not come from nothing; the legislature has delegated certain of its powers to the executive branch. In order to be banned from being imported, in the form of downloads, TikTok would have to be a threat to national security (the government said how yet, but they don't have to until trial) or involved in terrorism (the government has not argued this). They have to make a reasonable case as to how this is not simply banning speech they do not like.
It's also not clear whether a download is actually an importation, or whether the Department of Commerce has any bearing on a US company (Google) manufacturing new copies of a product based on a foreign design. (The Huawei case is far from decided!)
As for your third point: Someone did notice, and filed a lawsuit in federal court! This is an article about the ongoings about that case.
That does not apply on a number of levels.
1) this ban is an act of the executive, not the legislature. It is not a bill.
2) this ban does not declare tik tok illegal (It's not clear what it even means for a product to be against the law).
3) The department of Commerce has a long history of... regulating commerce. It's what it does. If this kind of trade regulation was indeed unconstitutional, someone would have noticed by now.