News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @04:20AM (#24614260)
The enormous capital costs demonstrates how expensive it makes solar and wind in simple terms. Even if we measure in terms of cost per watt hour stored and drawn over the lifetime of the batter it's still hugely expensive. Most batteries can support 300 to 1,000 charge and discharge cycles. So in terms of overall cost of storage, that's still in the range of $200 to $700 per MWh of energy stored and drawn over the lifetime of the battery.

This point is largely moot because we don't even have the manufacturing capacity to deliver the amount of batteries required. We only build 300 GWh of batteries globally each year. To reach 12 hours of storage, the US would need 6 TWh - 20 years of global production at current production rates.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by reitzensteinm on Monday September 28, 2020 @04:50AM (#24614477)
US oil consumption increased by almost 100x from 1900-1970. In 1850 it was just a few thousand barrels annually! That orders of magnitude more batteries are needed is not in itself an issue, as long as the solution itself is sound.

NMC chemistry (as used in Hornsdale) is good for 3000-4000 cycles, although it's about 50% more expensive than LFP, at least if you buy them from CATL.

This isn't going to be cheap. But it is feasible, and if you care about carbon I'm not sure how else you do it.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @05:12AM (#24614607)
> This isn't going to be cheap. But it is feasible, and if you care about carbon I'm not sure how else you do it.

How about we use the carbon free method of generating electricity that France has used to generate most of it's electricity for close to half a century?

We don't have to wait for a miracle that makes batteries cheaper, we don't have to scale up battery production by several orders of magnitude. If we built ten nuclear plants for every one that exists in the US today, that's enough for 100% carbon free electricity generation. It'd also provide enormous amounts of water if we use the waste heat for desalination. It also wouldn't involves consuming massive areas of land for solar panels. It would only involve technologies that currently exist and that we have decades of experience working with.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by reitzensteinm on Monday September 28, 2020 @06:49AM (#24615252)
You don't need a "miracle". Hornsdale was installed for $500/kWh, which works out to $125/MWh of storage at 4000 cycles. Prices have already decreased by over 30%, so we're probably at $100/MWh today.

If you need to store half your generation on a diurnal cycle, add it on to the LCOE of ~$50/MWh for utility scale solar, and you are cost competitive with the LCOE of nuclear today.

Lithium battery production is going to skyrocket regardless of whether it's used for grid storage; we're going to need enough for a billion cars over the next decades, even if the world converted to nuclear. Prices will continue to fall just as they have.

I am a strong believer that we should have embraced nuclear, given what we know now about climate change. But starting in 2020 with next to nothing, we're just now passing parity where renewables are starting to win, and the gap is going to get larger.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @01:27PM (#24619082)
$500 KWh is still much more expensive nuclear. Furthermore competition with electric vehicles isn't going to decrease battery cost, it's going to increase it. More demand for a constrained supply leads to higher prices. Wind is also geographically dependent, not all regions are capable of generating wind power at the same cost as Hornsdale. If your wind averages half the average wind speed you're going to have to build a lot more wind turbines. Nuclear power, on the other hand, is geographically independent in terms of it's output.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by reitzensteinm on Monday September 28, 2020 @06:18PM (#24621820)
Sorry I forget, what happened to the price of gasoline as it scaled up orders of magnitude?
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @06:33PM (#24621946)
The price increased. And this increase occurred over the span of a century, not a decade.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by reitzensteinm on Monday September 28, 2020 @06:43PM (#24622013)
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @07:53PM (#24622579)
Yup, the price of oil was a steady $20/barrel from 1880 through the 1960s. Now it's $100/barrel.

Now imagine what is going to happen if the demand for batteries increases one thousand fold (which is what is necessary to make grid storage possible) over the course of a decade or two.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by reitzensteinm on Monday September 28, 2020 @08:20PM (#24622776)
But you said it increased! It did not.

So why will scaling up battery demand a thousand fold over the course of a decade or two make it explode in price, but scaling up nuclear plant construction five hundred fold (from two to a thousand) not do the same?

You are putting your thumb on the scales. I think we're done here.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Saturday October 10, 2020 @02:56AM (#24737124)
Price is a function of supply and demand. Demand for oil was largely flat for most of the period from 1900 to 1970. It took 15 years to double from 1925 to 1940 [1]. And then another 10 years to double by 1950. It increased by a factor of 5 from 1960 to 1970, but in 1970 demand finally caught up with supply. And guess what? The price surged to over $100 a barrel.

Understand that even just 1 hour of energy storage for the US exceeds global battery production. If we try to use batteries for gird storage we're going to experience a battery shock in the same vein as the oil shock. That'll be terrible, because it will stunt electric vehicle adoption. There are much better uses for batteries than grid storage.

We're both putting our thumb on the scale: You're claiming that we're going to see a 10x decrease in battery cost, despite surging demand for batteries. I'm explaining that nuclear built at scale will likely cost 4-5x less than current nuclear projects.

The difference is I have historical precedence to justify this statement. We did build nuclear at a much larger scale during the 1970s, and it did cost 4-5x less on average.

Will battery production scale up like oil production did over the course of 1900 to 1970? Maybe, but that's an entirely speculative claim. The reality is that if countries start attempting to purchase grid scale batteries, we're going to experience a battery shock in the same vein as the oil shock following the Arab oil embargo. If the US tries the purchase 1 hour worth of battery storage the price for that amount of batteries is infinite. Or undefined. Because 1 hour of battery storage for the US is greater the the total amount of battery production in the entire world. The mismatch between supply and demand is that large.

Increase in demand, leads to an increase in cost, which in turn incentivizes increased production. The production of batteries is forecasted to increase substantially, but it's still well below what's required for grid storage.

1. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/World-crude-oil-producti...

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by jusssi on Monday September 28, 2020 @02:00PM (#24619458)
Sure. Just make sure you don't ask the French to build your plants. It's 2020 now and we're still waiting: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olkiluoto_Nuclear_Power_Plan...
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @02:13PM (#24619623)
Cherry-picking an individual plant doesn't change the fact that France produces electricity with much less carbon than most other countries, and often at an even cheaper cost.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by jusssi on Monday September 28, 2020 @03:33PM (#24620400)
Feel free to cherry-pick a recent success story from Areva / Framatome to counter mine.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @05:56PM (#24621646)
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by jka on Monday September 28, 2020 @06:16AM (#24615040)
Your arguments are the most compelling I've seen so far for more nuclear as opposed to renewables.

I'm still leaning towards renewables for various reasons, but could be swayed - could you share any more details about where the 12 hour capacity requirement and costs mentioned come from?

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by DoctorOetker on Monday September 28, 2020 @02:23PM (#24619757)
please don't be swayed, he uses lots logical phallusese, in this thread for example: taking the US electric consumption at face value as being the power to be displaced 12 hours.

note how this assumes that every joule you consume must have come from the storage system as if there were zero overlap between consumption and demand such that all energy had to pass indirectly through the battery system

also note how he typically treats reminders by others as claims of silver bullet panaceas: even if governments had devoted to fully switching to renewables and had solid plans distributed over multiple sources (solar, wind, tidal, geothermal, ...) and over multiple storage systems (synthetic fuel, batteries, flywheels, ...) in a way it sufficed our needs, it's not surprising that pointing at just one energy source or just one storage type, you'd arrive to the conclusion batteries, or solar won't suffice... even though in combination they might.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @03:17PM (#24620271)
> please don't be swayed, he uses lots logical phallusese, in this thread for example: taking the US electric consumption at face value as being the power to be displaced 12 hours.

Excellent point: The power that's going to be displaced is during the evening and night, which is when peak energy consumption occurs. The power that's going to be displaced is even greater!

> note how this assumes that every joule you consume must have come from the storage system as if there were zero overlap between consumption and demand such that all energy had to pass indirectly through the battery system

I do no such thing, not all energy needs to pass through the battery system. Of course daytime energy use can draw on solar panels directly.

> also note how he typically treats reminders by others as claims of silver bullet panaceas: even if governments had devoted to fully switching to renewables and had solid plans distributed over multiple sources (solar, wind, tidal, geothermal, ...) and over multiple storage systems (synthetic fuel, batteries, flywheels, ...) in a way it sufficed our needs, it's not surprising that pointing at just one energy source or just one storage type, you'd arrive to the conclusion batteries, or solar won't suffice... even though in combination they might.

In combination they might suffice. Do we want to bet averting climate catastrophe on a solution that might work? Or on a solution that does work? We know that nuclear power can power all of a nation's energy demands. We have firsthand examples of this happening. It's not contingent on unproven technologies like synthetic fuels, grid-scale batteries, or massive farms of flywheels.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Manfredo_1 on Monday September 28, 2020 @01:41PM (#24619250)
12 hours of capacity would still leave 20% of electricity to be fulfilled by fossil fuels. To get to 100% renewable we'd need 3 weeks of storage: https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/03/01/12-hours-energy-stora...