News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Files Patent Suit Against Samsung Over Galaxy Line ... by Bud on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:00PM (#2460905)
Yeah, exactly: Samsung was FORCED into using the exact same number of icons, arranged in the same 5 rows of 4 icons, in the exact same shape. Also forced into a 4-icon shaded bar at the bottom with the 4 key icons in said bar, and forced into using a near-identical "phone" icon in the exact same place, because after all, a light-green phone icon with a diagonally-slanted depiction of a phone handset was the only possible way to go. Samsung was also clearly forced into using the exact same means of depicting multiple screens of icons.

Come on. Samsung clearly didn't even TRY to distinguish their product, here. This is about as obvious as it gets.

Re:Apple Files Patent Suit Against Samsung Over Galaxy Line ... by uvdiv on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:29PM (#2461011)
The 5x4 layout seems pretty unremarkable -- should each phone manufacturer have to trademark their own layout (n,m), for nonzero integers n,m? Will small players be forced to adopt button grids like 21x1 if they can't license actually-usable arrangements?

I don't think it's reasonable that a simple silhouette of a phone, used as an icon to represent a phone, is trademarkable. The color is more interesting, until you look at wikipedia and see that mobile phones were using almost the exact same iconography -- phone silhouette over light green background -- at least as far back as 1989:

Nokia Mobira Cityman

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia#First_mobile_phones

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Nokia_150_and_nokia_1100.j...

The only difference is that the icon has been rotated and now has a shorter aspect ratio. Also the silhouette is now white instead of black.

Re:Apple Files Patent Suit Against Samsung Over Galaxy Line ... by cube13 on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:57PM (#2461079)
>I don't think it's reasonable that a simple silhouette of a phone, used as an icon to represent a phone, is trademarkable.

Trademarks are an interesting case, though. You can trademark common ideas, especially if you're the first one to get the trademark for that specific use. They're extremely focused in that they can only be used in a specific way. MS' trademarks on Windows and Word, for example, only apply to operating systems and word processors.

Re:Apple Files Patent Suit Against Samsung Over Galaxy Line ... by cma on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:32PM (#2461021)
Most of your points would apply if you substituted Samsung with Apple and Apple with Palm.
Re:Apple Files Patent Suit Against Samsung Over Galaxy Line ... by Samuel_Michon on Monday April 18, 2011 @07:14PM (#2461122)
You probably meant it the other way around: Palm's Pilot (1996) borrowed heavily from Apple's Newton MessagePad (1993).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton_MessagePad

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_1000

Re:Apple Files Patent Suit Against Samsung Over Galaxy Line ... by cma on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @09:34AM (#2462543)
According to Jobs, anything created while he wasn't there is not canon.
Re:Apple Files Patent Suit Against Samsung Over Galaxy Line ... by Samuel_Michon on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @11:19PM (#2465120)
Definitely funny, but Steve Jobs ≠ Apple, even though Wall St hasn't realized it yet.
Re:Apple Files Patent Suit Against Samsung Over Galaxy Line ... by Bud on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @11:56PM (#2465188)
Wrong on both counts. Steve Jobs IS Apple, as evidenced by the rather impressive performance of Apple since he returned as CEO, and Wall St. HAS realized it, and Wall St. is right.

Or do you think someone else is chiefly responsible?

Jobs built a great team, and of course he didn't do it all himself, but he sure makes one hell of a great figurehead. :)