Startups are about balancing a bunch of things rather than having some type of optimal stable configuration. Working in an office let's you balance a bunch of other things more easily.
But a startup needs to make money or it can’t pay people. You don’t just need code. You need a product and you need to sell it.
There's a lot of failed start ups in general. Doesn't seem like its a feature unique to remote-only projects.
A lot of the Apache projects came from companies. Although some of these were more like one person at the company developed it and the company funded and maintained it.
Did Kubernetes start in person as in in the same room? It was built by multiple people but I don't know if they shared an office space. I thought it was that they shared a building.
All of the other ones though are pretty solid examples of team-driven OSS work.
I imagine that many startups can and will be successfully fully-remote from Day 1, whereas other startups won't possibly be able to work successfully without close and constant in-person communication.
Larger companies can live with the slower pace the remote communication creates - exasperating as that can be.
I've been working remotely in the past 10+ years and I'm never looking into on-site work again! The time "invested" in commute with all the risks associated with driving are not worth it - even if it pays slightly better. But usually it doesn't. For example, in Orange County, CA you can't find a well-paying job - the best jobs are remote and OC is not a fringe case!
Remote work is the nightmare of micromanagers! Everybody else loves remote work!
The bigger question is, can the company quickly scale with finding on-site people around the area quickly enough?
Business is a cargo cult
After seeing it burn two different startups I was at, I am baffled why they burn money to have offices in a big city when money is tight (or they should be acting like it, rather than assuming they will always get another round at favorable terms)
When you are stable and profitable, having an office isn't that big of a deal. When you are burning money and looking down a cliff, maybe a $25k+ / mo expense is better spent hiring someone. Plus you can ethically pay people under market and both sides are happy (employee cuts their expenses by 50%+, you cut your payroll by 25%). Your employees will be happier, you get to pay them less, no need to buy desks, you can scale your business infinitely and you get rid of likely your biggest expense.
Startups could even spend a tiny fraction on improving their employee's offices. $1k yearly home office stipend would be huge for an employee, but a drop in the bucket compared to $1k / employee / month office expense.
VC funding causes people to make dumb decisions.