News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is Math? by username90 on Saturday September 26, 2020 @01:35PM (#24600589)
Math isn't a language, it has a language. You can easily invent your own language to describe different aspects of maths. Saying that it is a language is like saying that computer science is a language since people write C etc.
Re:What Is Math? by samatman on Saturday September 26, 2020 @11:31PM (#24604022)
That's certainly one way to parse it.

I'm with Max, from Pi. To restate his first assumption: Mathematics is the language of nature.

Cue Clint Mansell...

Re:What Is Math? by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday September 27, 2020 @02:28AM (#24604642)
It's a tool invented by man that can model nature. It isn't an inherent property of the natural world.
Re:What Is Math? by alanbernstein on Sunday September 27, 2020 @03:55AM (#24605013)
Would you say that symmetry is not inherent in the natural world?
Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Sunday September 27, 2020 @02:09PM (#24608747)
Symmetry is a property that our senses allow us to reason about but it proves nothing of the “inherent natural world”
Re:What Is Math? by alanbernstein on Sunday September 27, 2020 @10:25PM (#24612337)
It doesn't need to "prove" anything to be said to "exist in the natural world".
Re:What Is Math? by kevin_thibedeau on Monday September 28, 2020 @12:41AM (#24613045)
A qualitative description is not mathematics.

Consider an EM field. Do you think there is some daemon grinding out complex exponentials as it propagates? In reality some spinny thing is rotating and moving through space. What those terms actually are isn't precisely known but the phenomenon closely fits a mathematical model we can elaborate on to do useful things. That doesn't mean it's how reality works.

Re:What Is Math? by tim333 on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @09:24AM (#24638456)
Though it could be how reality works. Maths things like pi don't seem to need daemons calculating it for it to have a value. And perhaps likewise EM fields.
Re:What Is Math? by alanbernstein on Monday September 28, 2020 @01:43PM (#24619273)
The phenomenon of rotation is inherently cylindrically symmetric, is it not?
Re:What Is Math? by andrewjl on Monday September 28, 2020 @03:48AM (#24614073)
It has been demonstrated that humans have no easy way to universally distinguish artifacts of perception from empirically real phenomena. So I really take issue with this use of "exist". It's never that simple.

And that's before getting into categorization issues. Does Pluto "exist" as a planet? It'd be pretty non-sensical to say it stopped existing when scientific authorities changed its designation. But then was Pluto really a planet before that happened? Or was its planetary status a figment of collective imagination?

Re:What Is Math? by alanbernstein on Monday September 28, 2020 @01:45PM (#24619294)
Are you suggesting that the concept of symmetry may conceivably be an artifact of perception? Though I accept the statement of your first sentence, I find this application of it extremely hard to accept.

I agree categorization is a (almost?) purely human concept. I'm not sure how that relates to my question.

Re:What Is Math? by andrewjl on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:43AM (#24624481)
Yes. This extends not just to things like symmetry but also to what we think the concepts of "space" and "time" to be. The Critique of Pure Reason is the classic work on this.[1] There Kant defines the phenomenon and the noumenon, sort of as aspects of everything that isn't us. The phenomenon is what we perceive, the noumenon is the "thing-in-itself" which lies beyond our perception. Though there's an open question if it's beyond our conception, Kant left that unanswered, which is where the ensuing debate over the nature of math comes in.

Why does this relate to your question? Because we cannot prove _anything_ not to be an artifact of our perception, nothing that we conceptualize is necessarily inherent in reality. In a strict sense, reality is unknowable to us. In a practical sense, none of this matters because math seems to work well. Still, if we wish to be undogmatic, then we should approach questions of existence or non-existence with humility and not base ontology entirely on perceptual illusions.

[1] http://www.gutenberg.org/files/4280/4280-h/4280-h.htm

Re:What Is Math? by ahelwer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @01:50PM (#24600709)
Does not follow. You can use a thesaurus to find many different ways to say the same thing in informal languages.
Re:What Is Math? by username90 on Saturday September 26, 2020 @02:19PM (#24600930)
When you do math you invent new language, ie you add notation and describe what they mean. The math is the actual concepts, not the language you create, an other person could have structured his language for this problem very differently yet ultimately describing the same thing.

Edit: To clarify better, the way you solve math is that first you solve the problem, then you figure out how to communicate the solution. This can either use language people created before or you create new language, you can just use English or you can just draw pictures and have no words at all. Either way you are doing maths.

Re:What Is Math? by ajarmst on Sunday September 27, 2020 @12:19AM (#24604195)
I'd clarify that when people talk about "a different language", they're usually describing the notation used in formal mathematics. But that's a comparatively recent phenomena (most of it from the last century). For most of its history, mathematics was (and still is, most mathematics papers have far fewer uses of the notation than most laypeople would think) communicated with the natural language of its authors and their readers. The problem was that natural language was frequently too imprecise to easily describe things formally (inclusive vs exclusive or is an example), so mathematics writing became stilted and full of jargon and structural formalisms: "consider two values that are natural numbers and neither of which divides the other without remainder and ..." versus "$$ \{x,y \mid x,y \in \mathbb{Z}_+ \ \mathbb{and}\ x \perp y \}$$" (Edit: wait, Hacker News doesn't support MathJax?) Modern mathematics notation is more to simplify clear communication rather than to describe things that can't be described with words. That is, mathematical notation has far more in common with shorthand than it has with Esperanto, and I think that's an important distinction. When I read set-builder notation, what I "hear" in my head is English. (Also, you're begging the question by implying that there is an external concept/thing that the various languages and pictures are referencing)
Re:What Is Math? by butterthebuddha on Sunday September 27, 2020 @01:07PM (#24608138)
When people talk about different language, they mean more than just notation. For example, I can write "2 | 4" as "4 = 0 in Z/2Z". There is more than just a notational difference here.

A more non-trivial example: Say you want to say that 2 x 4 = 8. One way is to just write 2 x 4 = 8. Another way is to say that a finite set of cardinality 8 is the product of a finite set of cardinality 2 and cardinality 4 in the category of finite sets (in the sense that 8 satisfies the universal property of 2 x 4).

Re:What Is Math? by ajarmst on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:52AM (#24617250)
How is your example different from claiming that the statements "Aaron and Elizabeth" and "My friends whose names begin with vowels" are statements in different languages? I also note that with the exception of the symbols for multiply and equality, your final statement is written entirely in (an admittedly stilted and formal dialect of) English. I'm not saying that Mathematics is anything but beautiful and expressive---but the only way to justify a declaration that it's a distinct language is to do irreparable harm to the meaning of the word "language". And, of course, you make my point in your first sentence. I agree that what we call language is more than just notation. Which is one of several reasons (among them concepts related to things like mutual intelligibility, orthography vs. grammar, native speakers, effortless learning during early childhood, communication as an evolutionarily selectable trait, ...) that I disagree that mathematical statements or reasoning are the same species of thing as British Received English, American Sign Language or even Elvish and Klingon.
Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Sunday September 27, 2020 @02:13PM (#24608786)
Precisely. Language under the context that it is a restricted set of abstractions used to communicate a set of consistencies.

Language itself is an exclusive operation on the possible coordinates of anything within a universe.

Re:What Is Math? by ajarmst on Monday September 28, 2020 @03:32PM (#24620394)
Well, if we're allowed to just redefine the terms, you can make and prove whatever claim you wish, but its unsatisfying and ultimately pointless. I'm not sure why you think the above (which, I'm sorry, parses as gibberish for me) is useful given my assertion that mathematics is not the same species of thing as human language, as opposed to whatever the thing you're describing above is.
Re:What Is Math? by jschwartzi on Sunday September 27, 2020 @12:58AM (#24604330)
You don't really "solve" math. You apply math to a concrete model. For example, if you want to build a four-sided pyramid and all you have is a really big straight edge and a really big collapsible compass, you'd probably want to read Euclid first. And if you happen to be doing this 2000 years before Euclid you'd read some of the geometric methods his work was based on. To the extent the surface you're building on is "flat" the axioms and the theorems apply. And so you can square a circle easily using simple tools like cord and stakes. Thus you can build a pyramid with some cordage and a stake.
Re:What Is Math? by mennis16 on Saturday September 26, 2020 @11:28PM (#24604001)
Doesn't this still depend on what specifically "math" is referring to? Sure there is some underlying concept, but when people use the word math I think they are largely referring to the language that has been/continues to be built up to describe those concepts. Without at least learning the existing language one would have to rebuild a ton of foundations themselves before they could do much of anything. I suppose you could say the same thing about e.g. biology but I don't think it's quite analogous, as terminology is nowhere near as precise and things often don't abstract super nicely.
Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Sunday September 27, 2020 @02:10PM (#24608759)
In a way you’re just doing language associated to analogies and agreed conditions. So closer to games than math.
Re:What Is Math? by ahelwer on Saturday September 26, 2020 @02:48PM (#24601178)
Sounds identical to articulating a concept in any informal language.
Re:What Is Math? by beagle3 on Saturday September 26, 2020 @05:37PM (#24602361)
Yes, but the concept is not the language.

E.g. the word “carbohydrate”, or it’s equivalent in different languages, describes a concept; but the concept itself exists independently of any language construct that describes it. Similarly, in math, a concept e.g. “prime number” is independent of the many ways and many languages you can use to describe it. It just is.

Re:What Is Math? by wcarey on Saturday September 26, 2020 @08:33PM (#24603273)
It's less clear in informal languages that concepts exist apart from the language to describe them. This is one of the great difficulties in translation; different languages conceptualize the world in different (and sometimes incompatible) ways. For example, Latin has a variety of words for relationships of power that don't convey cleanly into English. The Greek word λόγος also doesn't cleanly render in English. Similarly for much of the Tao Te Ching. To what extent our language shapes our conceptualization of the world is currently an open question, but it seems like it's at least some.
Re:What Is Math? by unishark on Sunday September 27, 2020 @12:15AM (#24604188)
These seem like extreme cases that just take more words to translate due to limited overlap of shared experiences. If it never snows in Hawaii, the Hawaiian language may not have a word for it. But snow is a real thing apart from language. I think what is meant by informal language is more the structural rules, which ultimately seem to just be arbitrary patterns of behavior people fell into, instead of sometime deeper.
Re:What Is Math? by wcarey on Sunday September 27, 2020 @10:52AM (#24607055)
Those rules too exhibit cross-language conceptual shear. For example, English doesn't really have an equivalent of Latin's subjunctive mood, and our clause boundary system is way weaker. We use punctuation marks in a way that the Romans didn't (they used punctuation words in a much more systematic way than we do). Greek has a separate grammatical number for pairs of things as opposed to our singular and plural. Those rules, in addition to the individual words (perhaps) bespeak a different way of conceptualizing the world.
Re:What Is Math? by jschwartzi on Sunday September 27, 2020 @01:00AM (#24604343)
It actually does snow in Hawaii. People on the big island have skis and snowboards for the few times it snows on top of their mountains. It also snows on Haleakala in Maui which is pretty fun to think about.
Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Sunday September 27, 2020 @02:14PM (#24608803)
A concept never just is. For something to “is” it must exist and show me a prime number that exists.
Re:What Is Math? by beagle3 on Sunday September 27, 2020 @05:54PM (#24610425)
The concept of "a number that cannot be written as a product of two other numbers" just is. It might happen in some setting that none exist, but the general concept most certainly just is (and they can be shown to exist among the natural numbers if you insist - but they do not exist in e.g. Z_2 - the binary field).
Re:What Is Math? by srtjstjsj on Saturday September 26, 2020 @05:33PM (#24602339)
Yes. And concepts (math) aren't language.
Re:What Is Math? by dfischer on Sunday September 27, 2020 @02:15PM (#24608814)
All concepts are language.