News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by umanwizard on Saturday September 26, 2020 @06:25AM (#24597710)
Who cares if new people use it or if it looks modern? It’s working well for the people who want it. Not every piece of software has to be everything to everyone.
Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by zarkov99 on Saturday September 26, 2020 @09:32AM (#24598687)
Well I care, and so should anyone who would like to see Emacs live on for another 40 years. There will be major new areas of innovation, that will require massive amounts of work, and without an energetic and large community Emacs will not be able to adapt.
Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 26, 2020 @12:34PM (#24600030)
Well, as sad as it is for someone like me, who lives and breathes Emacs, there are already signs showing. There's still no decent support for C++, even in community. If you have a patience to bash together a number of elisp packages and write some extra config to paper over the idiosyncrasies of your project, then sure, you'll get something mostly working. But then just downloading Visual Studio will get you 90% there.

There's support for language servers (and I consider the existence of LSP to be a new hope for Emacs and Vim to stay relevant in the future), but it's arguably so-so.

As good as the Emacs community is, it still has pretty limited amount of time and manpower to throw at problems. I feel the wider development world starts to outpace this capacity.

Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by tonyarkles on Saturday September 26, 2020 @09:52AM (#24598864)
> There will be major new areas of innovation

I’m really curious what you mean by that, and how you see the world evolving such that Emacs, as is, won’t be able to come along with it.

Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by Dangeranger on Saturday September 26, 2020 @11:21AM (#24599459)
Imagine a world where your terminal isn’t emulating a TTY from fifty years ago. Gary Bernhardt gave a talk about this in 2012[0].

[0] https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/a-whole-new-world

Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by tonyarkles on Saturday September 26, 2020 @05:42PM (#24602389)
Pretty cool talk! I love some of the features he's added!

https://imgur.com/Gtytll1

An interesting thing that often gets forgotten or missed is that Emacs doesn't depend on a conventional TTY to run. It's already capable of displaying images either in separate buffers or inline.

From Gary's talk there, my thoughts would be that a number of the features he's put in there would:

a) be potentially better-served as CLI tools instead of baked directly into the IDE, with well-defined inputs and outputs. I have no problem imagining use cases for e.g. the crash navigation stuff outside of an editor (perhaps as part of an error-handling dashboard).

b) likely already be possible to build in non-terminal versions of Emacs, without having to design your own terminal and editor from scratch.

By no means do I think Emacs is a perfect editor, but I'm also very cautious when pondering "do we rebuild from scratch"-type questions. I'm always keeping my eye on other editors and IDEs, and with varying levels of difficulty, I haven't really come across too many useful things that wouldn't be possible to do within the current Emacs/Elisp environment. Awkward, maybe.

Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by stingraycharles on Saturday September 26, 2020 @07:23AM (#24597948)
It’s not that black and white. A simple hint when installing or downloading, “hey did you know that there are these starter packs?” would already do wonders.

It’s not that people are suggesting emacs tries to be everything to everyone; heck, by pure virtue of its extensibility, emacs is actually the one editor that could potentially be everything to everyone. But a simple startup screen, “hey, it looks like this is your first time using emacs. what kind of defaults would you like?” would do wonders and existing users would be entirely unaffected.

Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by slightwinder on Monday September 28, 2020 @07:02AM (#24615320)
> A simple hint when installing or downloading, “hey did you know that there are these starter packs?” would already do wonders.

Automating the Starter-Pack-Installation at virgin start and adding one or two out of the box would be better. Many people are not downloading emacs directly. On Linux you go through your destribution.

Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by aldanor on Saturday September 26, 2020 @07:28AM (#24597970)
If new people don't use it, both its user base and developer list will monotonically decrease until both reach zero which may happen sooner than it could've been otherwise.
Re:Toward a “modern” Emacs by yoz-y on Saturday September 26, 2020 @07:54AM (#24598087)
I think that's okay. I see that many younger colleagues and friends no longer use Emacs or Vim, preferring editors with Textmate heritage (sublime, vs code and so on).

I think the middle ground during the transition would be the worst of both worlds and there is no shame to no longer be on the top if the times change.