News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by yholio on Friday September 25, 2020 @04:58PM (#24594023)
Banks as private middlemen providing society with a payment system is an outdated and baroque system. Today, the whole payment system of an average nation can work over a single cluster of computers in the basement of the central bank, there is absolutely no reason not to provide this service for free to all citizens and businesses since it's a critical part of living in a society. The whole superstructure of banks, credit card companies, payment processors etc. can be vanquished with one blow, by issuing every citizen with a digital identity card which can be then used to access his free accounts provided by the government, no other paperwork necessary. Some resources should be spent on preventing laundering and fraud with the system, but this needs to be done in the banking system as well, with the costs passed on to the consumers.

I disagree with some of the other claimed benefits. Central bank accounts holding monetary base would not offer interest, just like paper money, and will always offer negative real interest when considering inflation. The government pays interest when borrowing from the banking system, and you can certainly use your central bank account to buy these securities (just like banks do today) but then you are no longer holding the risk free monetary base, you have a security with some non-zero risk of sovereign default.

The stability of the system is also not a given. Commercial banks run the payment system as an ancillary to their main function, and that is to match un short term liquidity, that is temporary savings and surplus of people and firms, and redirect those resources to long term investments. This is a critical economic role and for the economy to work it will still need to be provided in some other fashion, for example by a credit market.

This already happens to a large degree, for example banks offer mortgages and package them into securities that are sold on markets. This whole MBS process was behind the financial melt-down in 2008, since these practices were less scrutinized than the direct loans and deposits of banks. In fact, both are the same process: monetary base increases in velocity and is multiplied in the form of interest bearing securities that represent investments in the productive economy. The stability of the whole financial system is predicated on the quality and diligence of these investments, and credit markets proved to be notoriously bad at discovering this.

One thing to note though, is that when a "bank run" happens in the "shadow banks" of the credit markets, the bad securities are wiped out but the goods ones quickly recover. So the central bank can ride a financial storm by blanket buying paper with fresh money and let the market discover the winners and losers. Bank runs are self-limiting because securities drop to a value where they become enticing to value investors. When commercial banks are involved though, you have massive contagion since bank runs are self-fueling, once a bank is in trouble every investors starts to request their money, even if the fundamentals of the loans made by that bank are sound in the long run.

Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by solotronics on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:03PM (#24594065)
I wonder why everyone is downplaying the moral and technical hazard of having a single entity controlling all the issuance and payments in a country? At least right now if some bank sucks I can take my money elsewhere.
Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by yholio on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:10PM (#24594135)
Well, the payment system facet of the banking sector is so tightly regulated by laws and central bank regulations that you could as well consider it controlled by a single entity - the government. Nothing much changes, and in fact you can provide by law some basic rights of access to the financial system. Currently, in most countries it is conceptually possible for an individual to be rejected by all commercial banks without compelling legal reasons.
Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by RobertoG on Friday September 25, 2020 @06:03PM (#24594576)
The payments are already controlled by the central bank. How do you think a bank moves money to another?

If the financial system is a tree, the root node is the central bank, the second level nodes are the private banks and in the next level are the business and households.

By the way, this perspective makes clear that banks are not "only another business" as we hear sometimes.

Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by marnett on Friday September 25, 2020 @08:27PM (#24595401)
This is wrong. You can be charged with crimes that bar you from the banking system. Not to mention the credit scoring system can prevent the mobility you speak of.
Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by jimbob45 on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:25PM (#24594265)
>Some resources should be spent on preventing laundering and fraud with the system, but this needs to be done in the banking system as well, with the costs passed on to the consumers.

I feel that you glossed over the most important part of credit card companies. I would say 100% of the reason I have a credit card is their diligence in preventing and solving fraud on my account. I would imagine the same to be true for many financially responsible HN readers as well.

Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by yholio on Saturday September 26, 2020 @02:27AM (#24596838)
It's debatable if this should be a lumped and mandatory feature of the payment system. For all in-person transactions, payments should be non-refundable and any fraud should be considered a technical weakness. This concurs with the longstanding tradition of paper money, with consumer protection handled off-line by adequate agencies, the courts etc. What currently happens is that credit card users enjoy a separate layer of protection that is subsidized by other consumers - debit and cash users - that pay the same nominal prices. Due to the credit card oligopoly, retailers are forced to do this since rejecting one of the major card issuers means forfeiting a large part of the revenue.

For remote transactions, aside from discontinuing the absurd practice of treating numbers printed on a card as secret authentication data, thereby reducing fraud manifold, we could have a unified system where consumer protection is offered by a 3rd party. For example, before you are allowed to shop online using your central bank account, you must select a private payment processor such as PayPal, Revolut etc., and agree to their terms and fees, and they in turn would handle charge-backs for remote transactions.

Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by jcbrand on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:09PM (#24594123)
So the central bank can ride a financial storm by blanket buying paper with fresh money and let the market discover the winners

How can the market determine the winners if the central bank is propping up the losers by buying their paper?

Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by yholio on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:12PM (#24594156)
Because the buying would be indiscriminate, while the market can (and will, to an extreme degree) discriminate.
Re:Central Banking for All: A Public Option for Bank Account... by jcbrand on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:24PM (#24594252)
If this was true, "zombie companies" wouldn't be a term bandied around as much lately.