Then there is also the side effect of our monkey brains to give importance to people you see often. Stand-ups cultivate the feeling of "this is a team". It's important to show members what the team is.
Stand-ups however are not a requirement for a good functioning team. I'm leading a small team of senior devs and, despite my praise above, I decided against daily stand-ups. There is sufficient intelligence and communication, and just general professionalism in everyone in the team, that daily stand-ups are not worth the hassle and corporate feeling.
As a rule of thumb, if there are junior devs on the team, I would insist on having daily stand-ups on that team.
"Agile mandates post-it notes" kinda stuff
Standups could be very well replaced by a chat channel, for example. This way it's broadcast, recorded and can be a bit async as no-one needs their turn to speak
I used to enjoy meetings when I first started there because it felt good to have a break from staring at a screen all day but I quickly got tired of being invited to 90 minutes long meetings on project X where my input was only needed for one point out of the 12 on the meeting agenda.
However it's also nice to discover if work done by other devs interact with what I might be working on. Maybe I'm working on changing some logic in a module, and some other dev is about to make an integration for a customer which will involve that module indirectly.
He might not be aware of this indirect dependency, so I can give him a heads-up and now we know we must keep in touch over this work.
It's also good in case someone else has any good ideas for solving an issue. Maybe someone knows of a tool or a service which can do the job. Maybe someone has experience on that sort of stuff, so the dev doing the work knows who to ask for advice.
This is the only regular internal meeting I have though. There might be a case-specific one or similar once or twice a month, the rest is just ad-hoc with 1-2 others as needed via Teams or dropping by the office (pre-pandemic).
Like, what is wrong with my reasoning here? Meetings are maximally efficient when the exact set of people who all need to talk to each other are present, and no more. In a team of 7, only 1 or 2 other people might be affected by what I’m working on. The other people are just wasting time pretending to care about what I’m saying.
My experience working at tech companies in SF has suggested to me that most meetings, not just standups, suffer from this problem. The time cost of a meeting grows as O(N^2), and yet we routinely have all-hands, weekly syncs, etc. Yes, some level of communication is needed but when the time cost of these things is so tremendous, it seems irresponsible not to at least ask if what we’re getting out of it is worth the cost.
Meetings are apparently the one thing that no one tries to optimize, in our industry ostensibly hyperconcerned with optimizing things.
Disclaimer: I hate most meetings.