News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by btilly on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:10PM (#24569332)
How do you know that the people knew that the nuisance existed?

"Sometimes really loud jets take off really early" is not something that you would want to put into a realty listing, and is not necessarily something that would happen when you see the house. It might have been disclosed somewhere, but do you know how much paperwork there is with buying a house?

I can easily see someone not realizing that they would have this issue until after they move in. As much as they "should have known", they truly may not have.

Likewise with power plants, "You'll get a stench when the wind blows the wrong way" is again not something you advertise and not necessarily something you'd notice when you see the house.

(Of course, "You have to disclose all this crap" is part of why there is so much paperwork, which might or might not include some of it now...)

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by bradstewart on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:18PM (#24569430)
At some point, the buyer has to be responsible for their own due diligence. It's not like an airfield is small or hard to notice on a map.

I wouldn't buy a house without looking at the surrounding area in detail, just like I wouldn't buy a house without having an inspector check it out.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by nullc on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:17PM (#24570147)
I left an audio recorder over night at my place before a bought it.

But even that only goes so far-- e.g. it didn't capture that the local high school had suspended night games while lights were being replaced and after they restarted it produced a large amount of noise weekly. Fortunately we're far enough away and the buildings are well constructed enough that it's not an issue. ... but I would have missed it equally for a property closer to the school.

This is a place where I think cities should have wide-scale long-term noise studies and maps. It's an unreasonable cost to expect every buyer to conduct a local noise study, especially since you'd really need to run it for minimum of a week if not a month.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by s1artibartfast on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:26PM (#24571588)
It isn't the city's job to de-risk every private transaction. Why is it unreasonable for you to pay for your own study, but reasonable to expect me to pay for it. Numerous alternatives also exist, such as asking the neighbors, checking next-door, or moving out.

Lastly, many such maps already exist: https://maps.bts.dot.gov/arcgis/apps/webappviewer/index.html...

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by nullc on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @10:27PM (#24574695)
Sound pollution is a matter of public concern which is already regulated by the state.

An appropriate study takes weeks or months, since it would still be bad news to find out after the fact that one week out of the month or every other month has serious noise problems. -- which is an unreasonable amount of delay to stick on the private transaction (in particular, as a buyer you'll be sniped by someone less cautious).

Moreover, the data needed is essentially the same for all properties in an immediate area. This is a natural shared cost, and redoing it once off for each would be extraordinary wasteful.

Finally-- this entire thread sub-thread is about reducing state intervention by buyers being empowered to not purchase places where they're going to have problems with the noise. They can't do that without the information, they can't gather the information themselves on a reasonable time scale. The buyer can't demand the seller provide it (because by the time they meet the seller it's too late to start collecting it).

I don't see this as too much different from things like flood maps (which require rather expensive flyover lidar and historical watershed information, etc. to construct) that cities already provide.

> Lastly, many such maps already exist:

Yes, I'm aware. Which is also why I didn't think it was unreasonable to suggest. (though the DOT maps are understandably focused just on highway noise).

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by s1artibartfast on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @11:56PM (#24575095)
Digging deeper, I think my reaction was to the idea that this is a real need and necessary civic expenditure.

While sound pollution is a concern to some, and regulated in some cases. IF this were on the ballot in my city, I would vote no, as I don't think it is a productive use of civic funds.

It seems that it is a zero sum initiative that would provide a marginal benefit to a very small minority of citizens.

In this case it would benefit people who are: sensitive to noise,have the luxury to choose between options, know and use the service, and afraid or disinclined to talk to locals.

It would also disadvantage people who are willing to put in more due diligence or have fewer options.

I see this a very different than flood maps, which ensure safety and help mitigate massive costs of rebuilding communities.

That said, perhaps there is a commercial market for such information. How much would you pay for such a map before buying a house?

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by nullc on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:20AM (#24576500)
I would have probably paid a considerable amount (and not just for buying but as part of my search).

Part of the problem though is with the exception of people who are weirdly sensitive[1] or keep unusual hours, most people just don't know that sound would be an issue for them until they're in a situation where sound is an issue for them.

The end result of this is a significant amount of cost on the public arising out of disputes, including distorting pressure on zoning.

Munis do astronomical amounts of data collection already, e.g. to maintain culverts, curbs, and storm drains they have street-view like data collection performed. They already do targeted sound studies (e.g. for roadways and public facilities). Some urban areas have gunshot detection and localization networks.

It might well be possible to make a case that a sound study could lower costs to the public by lowering code enforcement costs and reducing zoning conflicts (esp. if the marginal cost of adding it on top of other data collection programs was minimal).

[1] I wouldn't say that I am particularly sensitive, but being in a quiet location was part of my justification for the purchase that I was trading off against other considerations-- so I would have been unhappy if it didn't turn out to be what I expected. ... I'm happy with the result, and having lived here a few years I think I significantly underestimated how nice it would be.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by s1artibartfast on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:04PM (#24580009)
IF most people don't know they are sensitive before they buy, how would the information help inform their decision? Also, im not sure how this information would help avoid any of the disputes you mention? If the noise is still there, and people are still unhappy about it, the dispute will exist.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by btilly on Friday September 25, 2020 @02:57PM (#24592991)
The main purpose of collecting the data on noise is to find was to identify where and how to reduce it. For example aircraft operators who violate regulations get fined, and highways are targeted for specific modifications to make them more quiet.

This is not a zero sum initiative.

Given that the data is already being collected, making it available to the public requires relatively little additional effort. The primary value in doing so is to document what measures have been taken, how effective they are, and to motivate public policy decisions about what further measures to take.

The same information is useful for private transactions. This is how most people will use the data, but is not the main public policy reason for having collected it.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by petertodd on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:48PM (#24572480)
FWIW, decibel meters with logging functionality are pretty cheap these days, if you want to reassure a prospective seller concerned about privacy. $60 on Amazon: https://www.amazon.ca/Backlight-Measuring-30dB-130dB-Instrum...
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by btilly on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:24PM (#24570217)
As I pointed out to another commentator, an airport 2 miles away might or might not produce noise for you. And whether it does depends on the flight path, which is not marked on your map.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by jaywalk on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:24PM (#24570887)
For the airport issue, you can just look at satellite imagery and see the orientation of the runway(s). At two miles out the flight paths will be pretty well aligned with the runway, so it's not difficult to figure out if you'll have low-flying planes over your house or not.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by btilly on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:33PM (#24571659)
Yes, if you know how flight paths work, then you'll realize that.

For most people it is another thing that they won't think about.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by jimktrains2 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:19PM (#24572177)
It's funny how everything is fairly obvious and easy to do once you think of it, but the hard part of any transaction, decision, or plan is actually having the thought about each of those things ahead of time.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by 01100011 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:58PM (#24569933)
I bought a house a few miles from Marine Corps Air Station Miramar in San Diego and signed several pieces of paper relating to noise and the potential for unexploded ordinance. I think CA has pretty good laws on the books for disclosing stuff like that.

I could see people overlooking it, even if it was shoved in their faces. Buying a home is an overly emotional process where people are influenced by inconsequential factors("I love the color", etc) but overlook serious flaws.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by gowld on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:25PM (#24571577)
Well placed typo. California's laws are indeed unexploded ordinance.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by reificator on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:51PM (#24571874)
The post makes sense to me with the supposed typo, are you sure it wasn't intended?
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by dmurray on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:16PM (#24572137)
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by reificator on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:28PM (#24572285)
Homonyms are not typos though.

I'm familiar with both definitions of the word.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:31PM (#24572309)
> Homonyms are not typos though.

Homonyms that are close in spelling can be typographical errors, and, because they aren't as visually-wrong as non-words, are particularly likely to escape notice when they are.

They can also be a different class of errors.

> I'm familiar with both definitions of the word.

You mean “the definitions of both words”, surely?

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by reificator on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @05:35PM (#24572355)
I'm sorry, I do not post on Hacker News to have reddit arguments.

> You mean “the definitions of both words”, surely?

This is not how reasonable people act.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @07:33PM (#24573532)
I don't find dragonwriter to be unreasonable. Instead, I find your expectations to be rather surprising. You expect to not be called out on misusing language? On a board with a large number of programmers, to whom the details of language use really matter?

You can think that this instance doesn't deserve the nitpicking. But getting all huffy and accusing the other side of being unreasonable seems to me to be rather over-sensitive.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by Jarwain on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @08:36PM (#24574048)
Ordinance doesn't typically explode, except in a metaphorical sense; ordinance does. Based on the context, the latter word is most likely what was intended.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by makomk on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:27AM (#24576833)
This was made slightly more confusing by you making the same typo; presumably you meant to say that ordnance explodes.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by VBprogrammer on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:20PM (#24569472)
We have an issue in our house about one week a year they close the M25 overnight (the main ring road around London) and the diversion brings large trucks along the residential roads though our town.

It's not a problem as such but definitely something I wouldn't have possibly known about before moving in.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by outworlder on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:03PM (#24569987)
> How do you know that the people knew that the nuisance existed?

Anecdotal, but the HOA I'm living in holds meetings about airport pollution. It's a major airport, that pre-dates these houses. It's almost directly in the flight path. They had to know that an airport... has planes landing and taking off?

It's not even that noisy as there are noise abatement procedures that are pretty effective. But as long as the noise level is above the birds they will complain.

Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by cjrp on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:17PM (#24569417)
Naval bases (and airfields) are pretty obvious on a map.
Re:Los Angeles hid power plant methane leak for a year by btilly on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:18PM (#24570160)
If you're on a flight path then you can be impacted by a base several miles away...when the wind is from a certain direction. Other houses at the same distance get no noise.

Flight paths do not tend to be marked on maps.

(Note, I used to contract for a small airline. Noise is more complicated than you'd think.)