Ouch. Color me disappointed as well.
After SOMA, I'd say they are good at sci-fi, period. Even with its horror elements removed, SOMA has some interesting scifi situations.
How did you feel about A Machine for Pigs? I felt the real story there was the way the father went crazy, and the role the church had, two really believable plot points. Not really the man/beast moster and so on which was less believable.
I do agree though, for what it's worth they have two projects in development right now so maybe one of them is more scifi.
I also think that Amnesia: TDD was Frictional's weakest game (not bad but just not as good as the others), in particular due to the more mystical "ancient alien" plot.
Personally I prefer A Machine for Pigs over TDD for that reason too but I was always under the impression that it was mostly The Chinese Room's creation and that Frictional's involvement was limited to the more technical and publishing aspects.
Although maybe the reason is that I find the Penumbra/SOMA setting to be much more believable and therefore unsettling.