I've noticed that a lot of permission boxes are disabled by default if you open the settings, but not otherwise. The optics are better that way: it makes any claim to care about your privacy look less dubious. It also catches people who go to settings and blindly click all the options to turn them off without reading the screen: they accidentally turn them on instead.
The issue is the flow to disable tracking cookies (maybe this is the right flow?):
Step 1: Click Accept to be tracked or settings for details
Step 2: Go to settings. Analytics is unticked. My understanding is clicking accept in the first page would still have granted permission.
Step 3: Go back?
Step 4: Click accept?
Why is clicking accept going to have a different behaviour in step 4 than if I'd clicked it in step 1? I didn't change anything, just viewed settings. Is viewing settings the opt out? Is there no behaviour and then clicking accept on step 4 _does_ allow the tracking cookies? What was the point of the settings page?
Yahoo's GDPR page has much of the same issues for me.
> Stores the information as to whether the user agrees to statistical analyzes or rejects them
> Stores the information as to whether the user agrees to cookies or rejects them
As for what @capableweb said, did they update something or what? Before consenting to cookies I CAN actually open settings and... analytics cookie by default was disabled for me.