News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swift on Windows by DaiPlusPlus on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @10:24PM (#24562308)
> We don't expect Microsoft to develop its proprietary APIs out in the open despite it having a large presence in the open source world, why would we of Apple?

.NET is fully open-source now and it is developed in the open. And not just the BCL, but also platform UI/UX libraries like [WinForms](https://github.com/dotnet/winforms) and WPF.

(Yeah I was taken aback too: if you told myself from 10-15 years ago that WinForms would be open-sourced under the MIT license I'd think you were mad - or that Microsoft went out of business after the Year of the Linux Desktop really happened and open-sourcing everything was their swansong).

Re:Swift on Windows by pkphilip on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:02AM (#24563163)
WinForms is just a wrapper around Win32 API - which is closed, and so won't run on other platforms. So in many ways very similar to Apple's position on Swift and SwiftUI
Re:Swift on Windows by DaiPlusPlus on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @01:39AM (#24563361)
Yes, but even-so it's now far easier to make an alternative WinForms implementation for non-Windows platforms. Mono had their own workable WinForms implementation a while ago (which was a clean-room implementation, IIRC), but now that isn't necessary.

WPF, unlike WinForms, is ostensibly fully separate from Win32 and so should be possible to port it to non-Windows platforms.

Re:Swift on Windows by colejohnson66 on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:22AM (#24566713)
I wrote a project about a decade ago that used WPF and was disappointed to hear later that Mono wouldn’t be implementing a clone. They actually recommended Silverlight if one wanted cross-platform WPF. But WPF is just so much better than WinForms IMO, and Silverlight was on its way out then.
Re:Swift on Windows by simonh on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:03AM (#24563507)
Mono reimplemented WinForms from scratch, and any port of WPF would also have to be a from scratch reimplementation. Same for SwiftUI.
Re:Swift on Windows by DaiPlusPlus on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @02:27AM (#24563631)
But they don't need to reimplement it entirely from scratch or as a clean-room implementation because:

1. WPF is now MIT-licensed.

2. Unlike WinForms, the bulk of WPF is managed-code, not a thin-wrapper over Win32.

Therefore anyone can now port WPF to Linux, macOS, etc - and they only need to port the "PresentationCore" part of WPF (i.e. the native parts that expose Direct3D drawing surfaces to WPF).

Re:Swift on Windows by tasogare on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @09:41AM (#24566930)
The opening of those libraries are really recent and they were not developed as open source.