"This doesn't feel true to me based on my experience" does not mean OP was lying. It just means they had an experience that you weren't aware was possible.
Expressing polite, respectful skepticism is fine; accusing someone of lying without presenting evidence of that lie is not.
Heck, colleges are not even allowed to ask your caste, only under what quota you are seeking admission!
Did you notice you just contradicted yourself too? "you will NEVER see [...] "dalit". And even when it days dalit [...]"
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Here's what to do instead: when encountering incorrect information, respond respectfully with correct information. If the person was honestly mistaken, then they learn something; if they disagree, they can say why, also respectfully, and we can hear out the different views.
This way, we can all learn something, regardless of whether the other commenter is persuaded or not. Best of all, you don't discredit your own views by attacking the other person unnecessarily. If you're in the right, that's especially important, because you don't want to discredit the truth. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
If you want to clarify to other readers that you find something very uncharacteristic or unlikely, then just keep it conversational and assume they are telling the truth. What would you say if a crystal ball revealed that their story did happened? "Whoa, I'm from India and I've never heard of anything like that, it's hard to believe. Which college/region was that?" would make the same point yet possibly provoke more info from other people/OP. And people are unlikely to downvote an earnest inquiry.
That would be an interesting discussion I’d like to see, but you derailed it immediately through accusations of bad faith.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Accusing someone of lying violates several of them.