News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by mellosouls on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @02:17PM (#24557999)
This is pretty pathetic of Facebook; and they stoop even lower by claiming embattlement solidarity with other businesses because of the pandemic.

A lack of safe, secure and legal international data transfers would damage the economy and hamper the growth of data-driven businesses in the EU, just as we seek a recovery from Covid-19.

Clean up your act, or leave the EU data in the EU; we all know you're not going anywhere.

Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by Rebelgecko on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @02:58PM (#24558438)
It's definitely an interesting architecture problem.

If the EU says that all data related to EU residents has to stay in the EU, what happens if I as an American leave a comment on a post by a friend of mine in Europe? If my interactions with Europeans have to be stored in the EU, will all of my requests have to be served by Facebook servers in the EU? Definitely won't be fun for latency. I don't think that would be an insurmountable problem, but it makes things complicated.

Let's make things even more complicated: what if another jurisdiction passes similar rules? Lets say all data pertaining to residents of New Zealand and Australia has to stay in Oceania. How will people in the EU and Oceania be able to interact without running afoul of at least one jurisdiction's rules?

Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by addicted on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @03:37PM (#24558869)
Those are edge cases that need to be resolved. In many cases there may not be satisfactory resolutions for them. And it’s almost always the case that the law will not punish somebody for an Un implementable regulation if they see that the entity made a reasonable effort to try and follow it.

Talking about edge cases is a distraction from the fact that FB is refusing to implement things that are very much not edge cases and do not have fundamental implementation challenges associated with them.

Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by dantheman on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @04:16PM (#24559319)
Those aren't edge cases - that's the core use of the system. I'd say most people have friends in different countries/regions.
Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by nickff on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @03:17PM (#24558620)
There would also be problems when people travel (either as tourists or to permanently move); what happens to their 'old' data, or their 'new' data when/if they travel back? So-called 'edge cases' become big problems when you have a large number of users, and fines/penalties are based on corporate revenues (rather than damages).
Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by vr46 on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @04:56PM (#24559781)
Cross-jurisdiction issues crop up all the time. Sometimes they must follow the route that provides the most privacy and this is compliant everywhere, sometimes there are trade deals and compromises are made. In a conversation between an American and a German, I would expect the American to get EU levels of protection. This is all pie-in-the-sky though, I’m sure.
Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by Rebelgecko on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @05:13PM (#24559979)
If I'm understanding the article correctly, the problem is that the EU levels of protection give EU datacenters a monopoly on the data. The regulation isn't compatible with other nations passing the same sort of laws.

If the US passed a mirroring law in order to protect Americans' data from being spied on by GHCQ, then you have two mutually exclusive privacy regulations. The data can't exist outside of the EU, but the data also can't exist outside of the US. Considering the competing goals (in this hypothetical situation where the US doesn't want Americans being spied on by the EU, and the EU doesn't want Europeans being spied on by the US), I have 0 faith in the governments being able to resolve this balkanization.

Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by vr46 on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @06:05PM (#24560524)
Possibly, but I think the key lines are "the US does not limit surveillance of EU citizens" and "there were insufficient safeguards against snooping by US intelligence agencies", which suggests that it's fixable, although the medicine is unpleasant for US-based-whoopee-you-get-free-data-and-you-get-free-data companies; The EU is operating pretty consistently, I'd say. They work like a club with rules that allows anyone to enter provided they follow their rules, and making the club very attractive to join so that entrants willingly make the changes. The US is generally not inclined to take other countries' interests to heart and is not renowned for equitable relationship-building, but it defends its citizens' rights and its companies' rights, so the EU does the same and Facebook blubs, it's just standard business PR.
Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by eridan2 on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @05:15PM (#24560000)
this is not about comments, it's about a lot of other interactions, many outside Facebook apps and sites - Facebook has info about websites you visited and links you clicked and webpages you liked, and where and when you did that
Re:Facebook says it may quit Europe over ban on sharing data... by matkoniecz on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @02:25PM (#24558107)
Also, Facebook leaving and creating void would encourage "growth of data-driven businesses in the EU".