Everyone expects the Fed to inject as many trillions of dollars as needed to the _stock market_ to keep stock prices up. The effects on the economy are more uncertain; but we know the Fed can, has, and said they will do "whatever it takes" to ensure an "orderly market"; which is just an euphemism for "stop stocks from crashing".
TINA. There is no alternative, and if you look at long term treasury rates (YCC has not happened _yet_), people are believing interest rates will be around the 1% mark for the _next 30 years_.
When the long term risk free rate goes from 2% to 1%; stocks become worth twice as much.
You'll be left with 5-100 megacaps, carrying less real revenue than when the debasement started. Consumers, SMBs, and employees will have had their dollars eroded.
<Speculation>
IMHO the method that the Fed uses to inject currency biases towards asset classes by controlling borrowing costs. In an industrial economy, this would typically result in direct investment into new equipment, and an agricultural economy the tilling of new land. However, growth in services or tech is rarely debt-financed as there are relatively low CapEx costs and high opex loads. Given the relative maturity of the industrial and agricultural sectors, there aren't many places in the economy that can productively absorb debt-backed financing.
What we end up with is relatively static asset classes absorbing massive debt-based financing and inflating overall asset prices. Unfortunately, several of these asset prices bleed over as costs to workers who need a home, a rent for their place of business, or an education to acquire skills.
While in a healthy economy, everyone's cost is someone else's income. As long as the Central bank is applying a QE strategy, your cost is a mortgage or a rent backed by a mortgage; the "income" side of the equation is just the central bank.
Asset holders benefit from holding assets that magically increase in price.
</Speculation>
Not necessarily.
Prices are dictated by supply/demand - and different goods have different amounts of supply/demand.
As so, it's theoretically possible to continually print money into existence, and use it all to buy Tesla stock, until there are no more shares of Tesla stock left for sale.
Under such a hypothetical scenario, INFLATION would only happen in Tesla's Stock price - as all this extra money spurred DEMAND for Tesla stock and wasn't accompanied by an increase in SUPPLY of Tesla stock. However, the price of shirts would remain the same - as none of this money changed the SUPPLY/DEMAND of shirts.
As so - inflation doesn't necessarily have to happen everywhere.
Note, this is mainly why CPI is a bad indicator of inflation - as it doesn't track the inflation that is happening around us - inflation in assets like stocks / real estate. This also explains why prices of real estate in certain cities are way pricier than others, and also why the stock market can be way overvalued when the economy is doing bad.
That's not what it was supposed to do. It also wasn't supposed to be policy forever but a carefully calculated (quantitative) intervention.
I'm not even sure it's working any more to boost stock prices.
I'm honestly baffled by so many people thinking that a contractionary stance would be better?
If the money injected by the fed is not making it to consumers, then we should expect that inflation measured via some kind of consumer price index would not move.
Consumers take out loans, that's a fact. Interest rates are lower, that's also a fact. Therefore, the money is making it to consumers.
If the Fed is able to expand the monetary supply without inflation, then that is a good thing (again) and the Fed should continue doing so until inflation does move.
>If the Fed is able to expand the monetary supply without inflation, then that is a good thing
Expanding the money supply alone does not seem like the right goal. Suppose the fed decided to expand the money supply by cutting a check to the top 1%. I wouldn't expect to see any inflation in the pricing of general consumer goods since that segment of the population just isn't competing for those goods.
Maybe that needs massive investment rather than monetary policy. Certainly QE has had many other impacts, but it hasn't led to a positive change in the measure that matters - consumer price inflation.
Nope, economic growth is not the goal. Inflation targeting and unemployment targeting is the goal.
I don't see how you can claim that the levers "aren't" working if you don't know what would have occurred without the Fed action.
I'm also not sure what you're hoping to accomplish here. Yes, quantifiable claims are better than subjective ones, but "no one knows what would have happened otherwise" is just an argument that justifies literally any action.
I'm saying having a model for what you're talking about and also having empirical research about what has happened with similar interventions on the aggregate is good.
Looking at a single intervention in response to a massive calamity and saying "well that didn't work because things were bad after!" is what I'm trying to critique.
Anyone who claims that the Fed is "out of ammo" is not worth arguing with.
Until it comes time to settle. Then they’ll have to either borrow more, by raising interest rates, or literally print money.
This is wrong. The Fed will keep doing QE to prop things up for as long as long as it takes. Do you read the FOMC meeting minutes or listen to Jerome Powell talk? There wouldn’t be massive inflows to equities without the Fed put (QE).
Facebook makes more profit than some stock markets as a whole (might be an exaggeration). Tech companies did well in the crisis, adapted better than others and were generally pretty good in making even more money.
I do agree: lots of people loose in this crisis. But we are probably in fact living in times of super inflation; the EU has for the first time ever taken debt; US and China race for debt.
All you can do (I feel): is watch and be taken for a ride. The gap between rich and poor will grow, so will the gap between “fast adapters” and “the good old industries”.
It may sound harsh: but the economy in the US probably doesn’t really care about those that lost the most and were the most vulnerable.
Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy may be the book we all should be reading (again) these days...
[0] https://vietreader.com/business/finance/16638-why-is-vietnam...
But.... It's the one asset class where normal people are allowed to leverage themselves heavily. And you can live in it.
In practice, by and large, you have to balance towards the former, which means your financial returns tend to be lower.
Which is... a good thing?
It was what, a little over 30% drawdown, that's a crash now? I've lived through 5 crashes then, hope to live through a few more.
> with worse unemployment than the great recession of the 1930s
Great Depression, not recession, and nope. During the Great Depression the unemployment rate hit 25% and was over 15% for most of a decade, here's the graph: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression#/media/File:U....
I did say started, not finished :)
Sorry Great Depression. We're in the first few months of this recession, which may well become a depression, and crucially is happening worldwide in almost every country and slowing trade at the same time. It's certainly been a much sharper shock than the Great Depression - the US has seen unemployment rise faster:
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/06/11/unemploymen...
And there has been nothing like these levels in the US since the Great Depression.
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/19/unemployment-today-vs-the-gr...
Since it usually takes these things several years to play out, I'm not convinced that the high water mark for unemployment has been reached yet. There are also hints that the true rate in early 2020 was more like 20% (department of labour statistics). We'll know in a few years, but this is certainly the sharpest recession on record (due to the imposed nature of it), and the only comparable is the Great Depression.
FANGMAN has lost $1.4tn in mkt cap since beginning of Sep w/#Apple quietly down 22.6% from highs, #Netflix down 18.3%, #Nvidia 17.2%, #Facebook 17.1%, #Amazon down 16.8%, #Google 15.9%, #Microsoft down 14%.
https://twitter.com/Schuldensuehner/status/13072058719073361...
Things are highly volatile right now. Frothy stocks like Tesla are moving 20% in a day both ways, which is neither normal nor desirable, CAPE at 1929 levels, 5 largest companies (all tech) were > 20% of S&P, IPOs reaching 140x earnings on first day (snowflake), fraud like We Work and Nikola constantly coming to light, companies like Softbank (of We infamy) making huge speculative bets on options. All the signs are here for a remarkable speculative bubble in tech stocks.
All this in the face of the sharpest recession on record, with worse unemployment than the great recession of the 1930s. I'm not convinced US equities will continue to provide the remarkable returns seen this year (with no basis in the real economy). Tech companies like Amazon need other tech companies to spend on AWS and consumers to buy, companies like FB/Google need other companies to spend on ads, companies like Apple/Netflix need consumers with disposable income. Everything is connected.