News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Which of these 3 email subject lines most grabs your interest?

At Correlated (http://www.correlated.org), we publish a new statistic each day based on the results of all previous days' polls.

Users can sign up for a daily results email, which contains the latest statistic and the current day's poll question.

I'm trying to figure out which subject line is most likely to grab people's interest:

1) [First name], here's your daily results email for Friday, April 15!

2) April 15 results: Cats, cursing, and crying

3) Today's poll: How often do you dine out?

The first option personalizes the subject line by using the recipient's first name, but aside from that it remains pretty standard from day to day.

The second option teases the latest silly statistic.

The third option presents the current day's poll question, which the recipient can respond to by clicking a link within the email.

What do you think, HN readers? Which of the three subject lines do you think would be most likely to grab your interest on a daily basis?

(I'm also open to alternative suggestions.)

( 7 comments | 4 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Which of these 3 email subject lines most grabs y... by mbyrne on Friday April 15, 2011 @11:21AM (#2450810)
1. A/B/C test it on your actual users. Everything else is a just a guess.

2. Having said that, my guess is that the first would generate the most opens. The second seems spammy and the third sounds invasive plus "more work."

Re:Ask HN: Which of these 3 email subject lines most grabs y... by rawsyntax on Friday April 15, 2011 @02:43PM (#2451627)
I would A/B test, but they all sound spammy, sorry.

I'd recommend coming up with a totally new headline

Re:Ask HN: Which of these 3 email subject lines most grabs y... by jakkinabox on Saturday April 16, 2011 @08:52AM (#2453853)
I say 3.

2 sounds like something I have to read and I probably wouldn't be bothered.

Re:Ask HN: Which of these 3 email subject lines most grabs y... by triviatise on Saturday April 16, 2011 @04:21AM (#2453539)
2
Re:Ask HN: Which of these 3 email subject lines most grabs y... by pitdesi on Friday April 15, 2011 @11:22AM (#2450818)
I vote for 2... but you should submit this as a poll:

http://news.ycombinator.com/newpoll

Re:Ask HN: Which of these 3 email subject lines most grabs y... by phlux on Friday April 15, 2011 @02:04PM (#2451451)
See, this is another reason not showing comment scores sucks. Instead of showing that I agree with you (number 2 is best) by simply upvoting you. I have to reply to voice my opinion.

So, this begs the question what problem is exactly being solved by not showing comment scores???

Re:Ask HN: Which of these 3 email subject lines most grabs y... by Terretta on Friday April 15, 2011 @07:41PM (#2452646)
His comment had two parts. How would I know you didn't up vote for the poll remark? I'll tell you how... By reading your comment. :-)