Re:Friedrich Miescher discovered DNA in 1869, a century befo...
by dekhn on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:23PM
(#24507353)
I believe Franklin only identified the structure as being helical (if you look at the fiber diffraction images, that "X" shape is indicative of helicity) and that the phosphates were on the outside, but not that it was a double helix, nor that the strands were antiparallel, or the specific structure of the base pairs (all of which were the key insights made by W&C).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Friedrich Miescher discovered DNA in 1869, a century befo...
by pcrh on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:49PM
(#24508469)
I think you are correct. The observation that was apparently key to W&C modelling the structure correctly was that the phosphates were on the outside of the helix.
In my view of the history of this discovery, this would possibly be the only thing "stolen" from Rosalind Franklin by W&C.
Nevertheless, despite the rhetoric that often surrounds this issue, it is worth noting
0) that Franklin was dead at the time the relevant Nobels were awarded, and they are not awarded posthumously;
1) the Nobel W&C received was actually awarded to three people, the third being Wilkins, who was a co-investigator with Franklin.
Re:Friedrich Miescher discovered DNA in 1869, a century befo...
by dekhn on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:21PM
(#24508799)
Actually, phosphates on the outside were actually part of Furberg's model from '52 - see Model I in http://actachemscand.org/pdf/acta_vol_06_p0634-0640.pdf
which W&C specifically mention in their paper.
I personally agree about Franklin and the Nobel- I think most people just read Dark Lady and believe its conclusion. I always recommend that people read Eighth Day of Creation, which presents a very compelling alternate view based on primary data.