News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK government’s plans to regulate the internet are a thre... by tialaramex on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:43AM (#24506013)
I'm going to guess that many readers from this US-focused site have assumed this is like the ACLU or something but for Britain. It er... is not.

It's a platform for Toby Young in particular, and a cadre of fragile Right Wing "intellectuals" to insist that it's wrong for anybody to even criticise their bullshit.

This gives you some sort of idea: https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/4agqbn/toby-young-free-sp...

I actually clicked this link before noticing the affiliation, because I thought it might have technical content and that would actually be interesting. It doesn't.

So, ignore Toby Young, but as usual for HN people probably aren't much interested in the actual article so much as the headline anyway, here's the technical consequences of the "plan" if you want to call it that.

This government (and its predecessor) have a core plan that relies on how the Internet worked in like 2016. Much of what people do is unencrypted and even when it's encrypted you can at least identify who they're talking to. So your backstop is that if sites are unco-operative (and we can assume many actively criminal and terrorist sites will not cheerfully co-operate) you block them in DNS. This is a known quantity, you can buy DNS blocking appliances at ISP scale. You can budget for it. The service providers will want so-and-so much money, you make them pass the cost on to their subscribers, hopefully it's not enough to cause push back that loses too many votes.

However even this limited plan isn't actually popular (it polls badly with certain groups and it's too technical for your doorstep representatives to have any hope of justifying their position so best to shut up about it) and from 2016 onward the British government has had plenty of more important things to do. This plan keeps getting kicked into the long grass. To be clear: It's a government plan, the government could make time for it on the legislative agenda, this isn't like a US House bill that Mitch won't even read let alone bring to a vote in the Senate - but they are far too busy to prioritise this.

Meanwhile it is now 2020. Meanwhile DPRIVE is deployed and ECH (what was once eSNI and now encrypts more stuff) is starting to shape up. So the DNS blocking strategy doesn't do anything any more. Now you'd have to rewrite the plan, invent new ISP-scale blocking appliances, goodness knows what those cost and what other problems they introduce, and you still haven't even tried to see if your plan does anything, much less achieves whatever nebulous goals are in your current white paper.

Re:UK government’s plans to regulate the internet are a thre... by 12elephant on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:57AM (#24506227)
Is it really that they don't want people to criticize their bullshit?

Or is it that they don't want their bullshit to be censored off the face of the planet? Whether or not we agree with their views, should they not be able to express themselves, and how they truly feel?

Imagine if your criticism of their viewpoints was being censored instead, so they got to speak un-opposed and un-criticized.

I constantly hear that people should "be themselves", and "should not be made ashamed of who they are". It appears this advice falls down when the people aren't who we want them to be, or hold views we consider "wrong".

If I hate a specific ethnic group, how else do you expect me to change, if not through sharing my views and then being challenged on those views. If you censor such a person, would you not then further radicalize them?

Re:UK government’s plans to regulate the internet are a thre... by tialaramex on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:10PM (#24507197)
> Is it really that they don't want people to criticize their bullshit?

Yes. Specifically the idea is to insist on the usual "balance" argument. If this BLM activist can say that police shot the unarmed black man in the back seven times for no apparent reason then a 9/11 Truther ought to be able to say that Jews blew up the Twin Towers using mind control.

If you say wait a second, but one of those is a fact about the world and the other is an insane conspiracy theory, then to them you're now a censor, an opponent of Free Speech.

They actually give the example of fact checking interventions from popular social media sites. In their opinion this fact checking is biased against them. If you watch a typical Flat Earth conspiracy video on Youtube for example it will add a fact checking piece to the UI that explains that er, no, it isn't and here's how we know.

People like Toby think that ought not to happen, because who are we to go around dismissing things as untrue just because of all the evidence against them?

Now, a cynic might think that professional contrarian Toby Young, who makes his living saying stuff that's obviously wrong benefits enormously from this useless "balance" and that's why he is in favour of it.

But who am I to assume such base motives. Maybe Toby is just very stupid and actually believes every word he says.

Re:UK government’s plans to regulate the internet are a thre... by 12elephant on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:58PM (#24508569)
> If you say wait a second, but one of those is a fact about the world and the other is an insane conspiracy theory, then to them you're now a censor, an opponent of Free Speech.

No, if you remove the video from YouTube on the grounds of "removing false information" you're a censor. This is what has happened to e.g. Alex Jones, Milo, and many others for example.

By all means, leave a comment denouncing their idiocy. Make a response video showing why they're wrong. Whatever. But don't remove the video FFS. It just makes them believe it more.

You said it yourself: "the other is an insane conspiracy theory". That's obvious to you, and its obvious to 99% of people. So why do you feel the need to remove it?

Re:UK government’s plans to regulate the internet are a thre... by konaraddi on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:20PM (#24512639)
False information spreads fast [0] and has real world consequences [1]

[0] https://news.mit.edu/2018/study-twitter-false-news-travels-f...

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/coronavirus-us-c... edit: to be clear, I think some lives could've been saved if we took it more seriously.

Re:UK government’s plans to regulate the internet are a thre... by drak0n1c on Friday September 18, 2020 @03:45PM (#24521115)
A donation from or friendship with the Koch brothers or George Soros is not a good reason to stick your head in the sand when you notice a dissenting voice.
Re:UK government’s plans to regulate the internet are a thre... by mellosouls on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:35PM (#24508307)
You link to a left-wing hatchet job article on a website that tends to promote woke articles and hates anything that challenges the notion that there are other points of view.

Here's a piece from the horse's mouth as a counter, (no doubt just as biased as yours, but from the source and openly labelled here as partisan) and writing in the rather less blinkered Quillete:

https://quillette.com/2019/08/01/why-i-want-to-start-a-free-...