News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by pbowyer on Thursday September 17, 2020 @08:39AM (#24503862)
But only in a "limited and specific" way, so that's okay [UK in-joke]

At least we're not the only country wanting to violate international agreements at present

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by akerro on Thursday September 17, 2020 @08:56AM (#24504007)
>At least we're not the only country wanting to violate international agreements at present

Countries do it all the time and there are conflicts because it all the time everywhere. UK is slightly different because EU is much stronger than UK, withdrawal agreement is important to keep food, medicine and skills flowing between borders.

UK government is planning and making first successful steps towards breaking withdrawal agreement before it's even in place. So why would EU even bother continuing wasting time and resources in this stupid game where they won't be the losers?

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by Voxoff on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:15AM (#24504207)
Well, it happens but rarely does it happen exclusively in the West where there is a lot at stake. (Would be interested in counterexamples)

International law, as an attempt to tame excesses of diplomacy, is something that has lifted up the West. It's brought order and prosperity. This move is yet another jenga brick taken out of the liberal West, thereby weakening the EU. The EU really needs to bother...

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by akerro on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:21AM (#24505723)
Just googling for:

France breaks international law https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20181017-amnesty-france-vi...

Spain breaks international law: https://www.icj.org/spain-conviction-of-catalonian-leaders-v...

Poland breaks international law https://www.ecre.org/human-rights-organisations-poland-viola...

I don't think I need to search for any about USA, each of us remembers at least 5 from very recent history.

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by chki on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:55AM (#24506189)
The very important difference being that these countries did not explicitly say: "We will break international law". You might think that's a technicality but in international law that's really an important distinction.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by Voxoff on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:59AM (#24506248)
I mean I did explicitly say the West vs the West. And self-determination is definitely a special case so none of these apply.

Again, the US vs the West?

I'd be surprised if its never happened. But the ensuing uproar is part of the politics - It's an extra hurdle for countries in a political maneuver. And a broadly positive hurdle.

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by throwaways885 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:50AM (#24506112)
> Countries do it all the time and there are conflicts because it all the time everywhere. UK is slightly different because EU is much stronger than UK, withdrawal agreement is important to keep food, medicine and skills flowing between borders.

[Citation needed.]

Plus, the government's argument (today at least) is that the EU broke the agreement first, so it's nil and invalid.

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by Brakenshire on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:34AM (#24505111)
The EU probably will lose the same in absolute terms, but it will be spread over 400 million people not 60 million. So in terms of rational policy making the EU should want a deal as much as the UK, but of course in practice if the impact is less diffuse it’s just less politically important.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by Silhouette on Thursday September 17, 2020 @01:53PM (#24507739)
European politics in 2021 will be interesting to watch.

During the endless Brexit debates in the UK prior to the referendum itself, IIRC the more credible analysis tended to have the EU27 combined losing more than the UK in absolute economic terms, maybe even twice as much, in the event of a no-deal Brexit.

The argument was made that the EU could afford to take that bigger hit anyway and was still in the stronger position in negotiations, because as you say even a somewhat greater cost would be distributed over many more people.

Then the counter-argument was that the distribution of any costs to the EU would be far from uniform. For example, one member state in the EU27 was all but guaranteed a catastrophic outcome if there is a no-deal Brexit: Ireland. This is part of the reason the NI border issue was such a sensitive topic during the negotiations. But more generally, some member states are much more dependent on the UK than others, or more dependent than others in some specific area(s). Another common examples is that the Mediterranean tourism destinations get a huge amount of revenue from the Brits each summer (under normal circumstances at least, maybe not so much this year) and in certain cases this represents a significant fraction of their entire national economy.

The EU and the Europhile leaders that most of the larger member states have had in recent times have been very good at showing a united front when it comes to Brexit, but as we've seen with other issues like the immigration/refugee situation and the pandemic, that solidarity can rapidly give way to realpolitik when times get tough. A lot of the EU27 member states are going to take a hit if we leave the transition period with no deal at the end of the year, and I wonder how well their faith in and support of the EU will hold up once real money and real jobs start being lost on both sides of the Channel.

At this point, I do not expect there to be a deal, at least not a comprehensive one that is useful for the long term, by the end of this year. It won't surprise me at all if the cracks start appearing on the EU side soon afterwards, though whether they will spread as quickly and as deeply as those likely to form concurrently in the UK is anyone's guess. It also won't surprise me at all if some important issues that are, in theory at least, EU competences start to get dealt with more directly by national governments looking to protect their own interests. Time will tell.

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by imtringued on Friday September 18, 2020 @07:29AM (#24515416)
The problem is on the UK side. They simply don't know what they want. The EU obviously wants to keep its members.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by PostOnce on Thursday September 17, 2020 @05:53PM (#24510409)
That "limited and specific" thing, it's been going on a while... I found something funny on wikipedia the other day:

Ad extirpanda (named for its Latin incipit) was a papal bull promulgated on Wednesday, May 15, 1252 by Pope Innocent IV which authorized in limited and defined circumstances the use of torture by the Inquisition as a tool for interrogation.[1]

"limited and defined circumstances"

It actually goes on to enumerate those defined circumstances, but I can guess how it turned out in practice.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_extirpanda

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by C1sc0cat on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:04AM (#24504746)
Well having some think tank say something and your senior legal establishment Is quite different.
[dead]
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by Kudos on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:10AM (#24504159)
It's not that funny, you must not understand how transformative the Good Friday Agreement was for Ireland and the UK, even if the typical Brit has no idea. It is a far broader reaching concern than software patents in Germany.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by qalmakka on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:32AM (#24505876)
I think the only way to really understand why the Good Friday agreement is important is to visit Belfast. You need to walk through the neighborhoods in order to see the gates, the Peace Walls, the murales and the signs expressing the grief and pain of two communities who have hated each other up to the point of killing each other, and still live just a few meters apart.

The whole city felt to me like a wounded animal that has only just stopped bleeding, and not it's begging for some time for its scars to heal.

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:32PM (#24508286)
When I was in school in mainland UK IRA bomb threats were a thing, the Manchester bombings still live large in my memory.

Even from a distance the importance of the peace brokered in Ireland is tangible, I feel.

What the royals and ruling classes did to Ireland seems as bad as anything they did elsewhere in the 'Empire'. It mightn't be logical, but all that history can't be ignored. The memories of oppression live long.

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by C1sc0cat on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:59AM (#24504680)
Probably because Germany only had the not very effective RAF terrorists as opposed to the UDF and IRA.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by CodeGlitch on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:19AM (#24504247)
I was refering more to the link I posted rather than software patents in Germany (actually I think software patents do have far reaching consequences).
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by hogFeast on Thursday September 17, 2020 @02:19PM (#24508129)
Er, you understand that the IRA was bombing UK cities? They bombed a hotel and almost killed the Prime Minister...yes, most Brits are very aware of the GFA (I am barely out of my 20s, and I lived in London and the constant bomb threats are something I remember...this is the reason why some train stations in the UK have no bins, they were a main IRA target).

Also, what most people who get their opinions on the GFA from people in the EU (largely dictated by Irish Catholics who believe that Northern Ireland will become part of Ireland) is that introducing a border within the UK is not any less of a problem than introducing one in Ireland. The UK govt's plan was to implement a solution which didn't cause any friction, it is clear now that all of the implementation was left to the UK and the EU washed it's hands of everything (again, the whole principle of GFA is that this is everyone's problem). If you are a Protestant in Northern Ireland though, the EU's position is/has been very worrying and contrary to the GFA in every degree (a principle of the GFA is that Northern Ireland is part of the UK, the EU issuing legal opinions and advising the Irish govt that NI would still be part of the EU if it left the UK does not suggest they understand what the GFA says at a fundamental level).

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by pjc50 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:18AM (#24504235)
This is unusual not only because of the possible impact on the Northern Ireland peace treaty, but because it's an agreement that was only just made by the same government. Which makes the whole process look particularly stupid and insulting.

It's also the deliberateness that has upset people - breaching a complex agreement inadvertently is very different from setting out to do it deliberately.

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by growlist on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:53AM (#24504615)
The EU do it all the time. But I guess that doesn't count for some reason or other...
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by czzr on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:26AM (#24505020)
Could you give one example? (Of making an agreement and then threatening to intentionally break it very soon after?)
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by blibble on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:26AM (#24505793)
airbus state aid is the biggest recent example: knowingly providing unlawful subsidy against WTO rules

the EU ignored its WTO state aid comittments when it suited it, and now is trying to force a much much stronger version of the rules that it routinely breaks, onto the UK

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by johnnyfaehell on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:12AM (#24504174)
To be fair, the leavers outlets seem to be the ones covering it the most. It's also a big deal because the country just made the agreement, it's not like it's 35 years old and everyone who made it is no longer around. It was made by the guy who is going to break it.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by zoobab on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:06AM (#24504120)
This is what several lawyers told me, people are making a fuss about the UK breaking the Withdrawal Agreement, but other countries do the same in other fields.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by starfallg on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:41AM (#24504481)
Let's take a step back and look at the situation. You are saying with a straight face several lawyers told you that the UK government deliberately breaking an important international agreement that was negotiated and signed by the same people just months ago is comparable to other countries inadvertently breaking some patent agreement signed decades ago. A matter that several high-ranking British officials had a problem with to the point of resigning in the past few days. Only on the interwebs do people fall for this tosh.
Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by detritus on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:50AM (#24504578)
The UK was one of the most compliant EU members.

Personally I'd've preferred staying in the EU and exercising a little more 'flexibility' in interpreting bloc rules to suit our tastes, as some other EU states are wont to do.

Re:Germany will violate international agreements with Unitar... by C1sc0cat on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:01AM (#24504704)
Applying the national interest in the case of ARM or even Cadbury (if France can do it for Danone)