1) They are skewed by a few 'elite' metro areas (which are best avoided by those without very high-paying jobs).
2) The houses are nicer and have more 'features', which cost money.
And that if you remove the high COL areas, and control for the amenities, you will find costs are flat or decreasing.
The university in town is over a hundred years old, and many of the dorms are that old too. Most have no air conditioning, and have insufficient power for a resident to add a window air conditioner without special approval.
And the parents and students describe them as, "practically unlivable", "bad for the students' education, and all of that. There are numerous schemes around to get that special permission. And many scheme to move out ASAP. These are folks borrowing tens-of-thousands of dollars to go to school, and yet still go even deeper into debt for better housing, when the cheap option is right in front of them.
100 years ago no one would have thought twice about the exact same conditions. I doubt anyone would have thought twice about it even 50 years ago.
People just expect a certain level of amenities, and are willing to pay to get them.
I also stayed in house with bad insulation and it affected my health. 100 years ago, my health would be affected the same way whether better house would be available or not.
Maybe they are all irrational. Or maybe those dorms are really in bad shape.
The point is that it is a somewhat new amenity that people value and are willing to pay for. and that makes housing more expensive.
Almost nothing else needs to be upgraded.
And being too hot definitely impacts the ability to focus.
It's not clear what kind of houses you are envisioning.
Go to Zillow or Hotpads (rentals) & search for less prestigious homes. You still don't get places that can be afforded with a HS Graduate income.
tl;dr: People can't move out in their 20s because of math.
2019 39,156
2018 36,734
2017 36,553
2017 35,970
2016 35,375
2015 34,157
2014 32,619
2013 33,008
2013 31,691
2012 31,549
2011 31,389
2010 31,208
2009 31,690
2008 32,096
2007 33,131
2006 33,496
2005 32,855
2004 32,368
2003 32,433
2002 32,483
2001 33,077
2000 33,267
1999 32,692
1998 31,629
1997 30,657
1996 29,521
1995 28,788
1994 28,332
1993 27,564
1992 26,593
https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income-p...It has increased even faster than average housing costs. To be fair, that's is expected because rich people don't spend the same percentage their income on housing as most other people.
My main point is, people are spending more on housing. It's not a mirage. It is highly concentrated where there are jobs, but of course people move to where the jobs are. It's facile to say they should move somewhere else, or that they are getting "more" for their housing.
House sizes have grown a lot too. When you factor that in, you get to what the OP stated: per square foot, housing prices have been remarkably constant (and for much longer than his 1990 to 2020 window).
When you factor in that houses are now vastly more energy efficient, safe, with niceties like central air, then modern home buyers are likely getting the best deals in history.
We have low interest rates today, but we aren't inflating out of our debt like generations past did.
I think you mean for the first year. With higher inflation everyone got big wage rises each year which quickly made mortgages more affordable. Now wages are stagnating so even 10 years later most people dont earn much more than when they first took out the mortgage.
Grows in expenditures does not immediately imply growth in costs.
Here is the data adjusted for constant 2020 dollars: