News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s... by Animats on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:26AM (#24490080)
It was, before Google. It cost about US$120 million to get Big Dog working. At least those were the reported DARPA contract amounts.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s... by amelius on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @06:30AM (#24491281)
Funny because yesterday there was a post on HN from a guy who made a DIY robot that looked very much like a small Big Dog.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24484129

Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s... by lioeters on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @08:03AM (#24491763)
This is a trend that gives me hope for the future. There's ever-increasingly advanced technology and technical knowledge accessible/affordable to the public, both hardware and software. What used to cost the military millions of dollars to develop, are now mass-produced and distributed, to fit in a pocket or to build one yourself.

Sure, the cutting edge stuff will always be in the realm of experts with funding, but the pace of progress in technology is such that there seem to be plenty of opportunities for innovation from the grassroots level, serious amateurs and hobbyists.

It kinda feels similar to the early era of personal computers, where anybody with interest and ideas could enter the field, learn things on their own, and even contribute to its advancement.

Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s... by Retric on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @09:20AM (#24492426)
I don’t think it’s advancing technology that’s allowing this. It’s not physically constructing or programming a robot that’s so expensive, it’s iteration of designs to get to that point. A hobbyist can build a small working jet engine at home, but their hardly starting from scratch.

Further, building a modern full scale General Electric GE90 is extremely far beyond what a hobbyist can accomplish. If anything the true cutting edge is getting ever further out of reach. A few peasants could build a full scale trebuchet, good luck getting your friends together to build a F-22.

Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s... by zalkota on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:47PM (#24496009)
It’s also the availability of material and technology.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s... by Animats on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @01:42PM (#24495118)
That just seems to move along in little tiny steps. No balance or slip recovery shown. That's the wind-up toy level of walking.[1]

Still, it shouldn't be that hard to make a small version of Big Dog technology now. They put a lot of money into fast hydraulic servos, which you no longer need for anything smaller than a horse. Gyros and accelerometers are cheap now, because they're phone parts. Motors and motor controllers are much better and cheaper now. Big Dog's compute power was a Pentium 4, which is nothing today. Force feedback sensors for the feet are still expensive, because there's no mass market. You need those for slip control.

[1] https://www.walmart.com/ip/Wind-Up-Wooly-Walker/194850858