Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by onion2k on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @01:25AM
(#24489800)
Why walk when you can fly?
Gravity.
Overcoming gravity takes a lot of energy, and if you're only moving a relatively short distance it's a huge waste getting a payload in to the air if there's an acceptable alternative.
For long distances fixed wing drones will definitely be better though.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by taneq on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @01:10AM
(#24489734)
Maybe because you want a robot with more than 30 minutes' autonomy?
Wheels (if practical) are best. Then legs (or wheel/leg hybrids). Then fixed wing (if you have somewhere you can take off and land). Multirotors are easy and fun but only practical for short missions.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by echelon on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:02AM
(#24489978)
There aren't fixed wing drones with VTOL? I'd imagine something like an Osprey would do well.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by taneq on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:42AM
(#24490145)
There are, but I was trying to keep it short. Alphabet's "Project Wing" drones work like this, for example. They seem a bit inelegant though.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by hengheng on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:30AM
(#24490093)
As well as an Osprey, or as well as a motorcycle with a sidecar. They are practical, but far from elegant or efficient.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by baddox on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @01:53AM
(#24489932)
Regular old small RC planes can do a heck of a lot more than 30 minutes. Also, the Spot only has 90 minutes of battery life.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by mattigames on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @03:44AM
(#24490437)
Backwards compatibility is one of the reasons, meaning an humanoid form can interact with all the interfaces that humans already use in day to day basis, think push/pull doors, grabbing two-handed objects or pushing a car; as well as the ability to be aid by other machines without wasting their own energy: think using electric stairs, elevators, boarding a car/bus/train, sitting down at a computer desk (so hands stay on while legs are off). Plus doing all that without the risks that spinning blades bring.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by accurrent on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @12:51AM
(#24489639)
Drones run out of battery and have huge spinning blades that can take out somebody's eye. They might on occasion also fall out of the sky.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by de_watcher on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:39AM
(#24490734)
I don't think that flying like a bird is simpler than walking like a human.
Flying like a quadcopter is more like walking like a cart.
Re:Boston Dynamics CEO talks profitability and the company’s...
by dragonelite on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:58AM
(#24490833)
Can't do regime change with only air power, you need ground troops.
Why walk when you can fly?