News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tracking users via CSS by achairapart on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:40AM (#24480521)
Ad-blockers have been around for years and I have always wondered why the Ad industry has not moved to server-side yet. Then I realized that maybe they weren't hit at all by this, but actually that helped with that 50% budget they often claim go to waste in advertising.

Much like Nigeriam Scams self-select the most naive users with their silly stories, some advertisers may likely get better impression/click ratios once the savvy users are out of their game.

Re:Tracking users via CSS by thehappypm on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:39AM (#24482500)
The ad industry has overwhelmingly moved to server side. Google AdWords, Facebook ads, Instagram ads, sponsored search results on travel sites. Server side means you need more trust that it’s an actual user and not a server farm, so it’s less usable outside the walled gardens.
Re:Tracking users via CSS by nieve on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @02:10AM (#24490006)
This is also part of why uBlock and others blocking ad elements via heuristics as well as URL patterns is vital and almost certainly a chunk of why Google doesn't look favorably on those techniques.
Re:Tracking users via CSS by bweitzman on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:10AM (#24481343)
Server side tracking would mean that ad companies don't have access to cookies + user fingerprints, so they would be less effective at serving targeted ads.
Re:Tracking users via CSS by ffpip on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:55AM (#24481884)
Why so?

Do the tracking inside the browser, send it back, render the ad server side and send it to the user?

It's already being implemented in many places.

Re:Tracking users via CSS by bweitzman on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:54PM (#24483476)
Most ad blockers also block the tracking, not just the displaying of ads, so the benefit here would likely be marginal.

That said, I think minimally-tracked (i.e based on what the website you're using knows about you) server side ads would be a great step forward for both user privacy + ethical content consumption, I just don't see advertisers jumping at the opportunity.

Re:Tracking users via CSS by theamk on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @01:14AM (#24489746)
User goes to shoes.com, which loads ads from adserver.com, which sets a tracking cookie on domain adserver.com

User goes to news.com, which loads ads from adserver.com. Adserver.com sees the cookie, and shows the ads about shoes.

If you do everything on the server side, shoes.com won't be able to place a global tracking cookie. So when the user goes to news.com, they'll have to see the generic ad, and not a targeted one.

Re:Tracking users via CSS by ffpip on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @04:01AM (#24490523)
User goes to shoes.com. Adserver.shoes.com acts as frontend for adserver.com. Adserver.com sends a cookie and adserver.shoes.com sets it.

User goes to news.com. adserver.news.com loads ads from adserver.com . Adserver.com checks cookie from adserver.shoes.com and and generates ads server side and shows it with the news.

Re:Tracking users via CSS by theamk on Wednesday September 16, 2020 @11:39AM (#24493694)
> Adserver.com checks cookie from adserver.shoes.com

1. This is not possible from server-side. The way cookies work, cookies set by adserver.shoes.com are only visible from documents hosted on *.shoes.com domains. And if the tracking is done client-side, by image, iframe or some other remote call, then this is trivially detected and blocked by adblocker.

2. How did "adserver.com" knew to check for "adserver.shoes.com" cookies? there might be hunderds clients, and trying to load cookies from every domain (adserver.shoes.com, adserver.computers.com, adserver.travel-to-india.com and so on) will take way too long.

Re:Tracking users via CSS by tinus_hn on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:34AM (#24482409)
Do you think the ads are ‘rendered’ client side? Also you have to specify what server side means because the ad networks don’t trust the web sites their ads are on.
Re:Tracking users via CSS by ffpip on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:43PM (#24483332)
By server side, I mean, everything is loaded on servers as a single file and served as a blob that adblockers can't block or read.

Like Google AMP.

Client site rendering can easily be blocked by just domain blocking.