News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The compositor is evil by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:07AM (#24478059)
We can already do this (without GPUs, and quite likely on them). It is done, for example, by a certain class of reverb algorithm which more or less literally "raytraces" the sound in room. It's not the most efficient way to implement a reverb (convolution algorithms are better for this). But it does allow for a large degree of control that convolution does not.

In addition, you may also consider physical modelling synthesis to be an example of this. Look up Pianoteq. It is a physical modelled piano that literally does all the math for the sound from a hammer of particular hardness striking a string of given size and tension at a particular speed, and then that sound generating resonances within the body of the piano and other strings, and then out into the room and interacting with microphone placement, lid opening etc. etc.

Most (not all) people agree that Pianoteq is the best available synthetic piano. It's all math, no samples.

There are similar physical modelling synth engines for many other kinds of sounds, notably drums. They are not particular popular because they use more CPU than samples and can be complicated to tweak. They also really benefit from a more sophisticated control surface/instrument than most people have access to (i.e. playing a physically modelled drum from a MIDI keyboard doesn't really allow you to get into the nuances of the drum).

There are no comments on this comment yet.