Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility
by dragonwriter on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:25PM
(#24477313)
Human rights are a subset of politics. (It's fashionable to label as “nonpolitical” any matter of politics that the speaker thinks is important, as if “politics” as a label only applied to trivialities, but that's not what it means and, more relevantly, not why HN often prefers to avoid things that are in that domain but not particularly intellectual novelties.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility
by bonchicbongenre on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:43PM
(#24477399)
No. Absolutely not. Politics often impinges on human rights, yes. But human rights are not a subset of politics, and absolutely should not be couched in political terms. Issues that are rightly called political are those over which reasonable people may disagree. This highlights that "politics" doesn't only apply to trivialities --myriad real political issues come to mind. My point here is that to argue that this particular issue is political would be beyond the pale, as support of the alleged actions is not a humanly just or reasonable position: one could certainly make it into a political issue, if one were heartless enough, but such evil isn't worth discussion. This is not a political issue. Deciding that it is one would be despicable.
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility
by jonahbenton on Monday September 14, 2020 @11:21PM
(#24477594)
It's the other way around.
Politics is that which fills the space when violence and scarcity do not dominate psychic considerations.
Political discussions can only occur in a context where there are human rights, where human beings in authoritative positions adhere to laws and rules related to their jobs.
Public talk that defends the systemic, ungoverned practice of violence is not political, it's propaganda (and worse).
Human rights comes first. Then politics.
Cheers.
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility
by bonchicbongenre on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:04AM
(#24478043)
Very well said. Thank you
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility
by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:44AM
(#24477952)
Corporate laws are a subset of politics.
Labor practices are a subset of politics.
Internet governance is a subset of politics.
Systemd vs others is a subset of politics.
Compensation packages are a subset of politics.
Stock ownership is a subset of politics.
Available food is a subset of politics.
Water purity is a subset of politics.
Air quality is a subset of politics.
Power generation is a subset of politics.
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility
by sudosysgen on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:41PM
(#24477388)
Technically, politics is just "what shoud we do". Almost every discussion is political if you want to work by a strict standard.