News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by bonchicbongenre on Monday September 14, 2020 @05:04PM (#24475139)
Before anyone flags this for being "political": don't. This is about human rights, not politics. Don't conflate the two.
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by dragonwriter on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:25PM (#24477313)
Human rights are a subset of politics. (It's fashionable to label as “nonpolitical” any matter of politics that the speaker thinks is important, as if “politics” as a label only applied to trivialities, but that's not what it means and, more relevantly, not why HN often prefers to avoid things that are in that domain but not particularly intellectual novelties.)
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by bonchicbongenre on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:43PM (#24477399)
No. Absolutely not. Politics often impinges on human rights, yes. But human rights are not a subset of politics, and absolutely should not be couched in political terms. Issues that are rightly called political are those over which reasonable people may disagree. This highlights that "politics" doesn't only apply to trivialities --myriad real political issues come to mind. My point here is that to argue that this particular issue is political would be beyond the pale, as support of the alleged actions is not a humanly just or reasonable position: one could certainly make it into a political issue, if one were heartless enough, but such evil isn't worth discussion. This is not a political issue. Deciding that it is one would be despicable.
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by jonahbenton on Monday September 14, 2020 @11:21PM (#24477594)
It's the other way around.

Politics is that which fills the space when violence and scarcity do not dominate psychic considerations.

Political discussions can only occur in a context where there are human rights, where human beings in authoritative positions adhere to laws and rules related to their jobs.

Public talk that defends the systemic, ungoverned practice of violence is not political, it's propaganda (and worse).

Human rights comes first. Then politics.

Cheers.

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by bonchicbongenre on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:04AM (#24478043)
Very well said. Thank you
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:44AM (#24477952)
Corporate laws are a subset of politics. Labor practices are a subset of politics. Internet governance is a subset of politics. Systemd vs others is a subset of politics. Compensation packages are a subset of politics. Stock ownership is a subset of politics. Available food is a subset of politics. Water purity is a subset of politics. Air quality is a subset of politics. Power generation is a subset of politics.
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by sudosysgen on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:41PM (#24477388)
Technically, politics is just "what shoud we do". Almost every discussion is political if you want to work by a strict standard.
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by aaron695 on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:51PM (#24477447)
> ‘Like an Experimental Concentration Camp’

Not political at all? Do we really think the USA is running something close to a Experimental Concentration Camp? Exactly what are they experimenting on, what don't we know about hysterectomies?

Or do we think the USA is making women infertile as a form of population control? Seriously?

I suspect it follows your politics which is why it's "not political". We aren't conflating anything.

It's an important story nonetheless.

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by sudosysgen on Monday September 14, 2020 @10:54PM (#24477463)
Why do you think that people are being sterilized in a camp at the border at which people are not allowed the right for a trial, did not commit any crimes, and are not allowed to leave? Seriously, I'm hoping there is an explanation that is less horrific.
[dead]
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by sudosysgen on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:17AM (#24477830)
The US has been systematically sterilizing indigenous populations up until the 70s. Why do you think we did that? If we're willing to get sordid, there are definitely reasons to do so; maiming people at the border sends a strong message to would-be asylum seekers, for one. For another, there are people in ICE with strong white supremacist tendencies. We have camps right now where people are not allowed a fair trial, and are not allowed to leave. This is very, very, very fucked.

And no, they don't get any compensation for anything. They don't have a US bank account. They are detainees in a weird legal limbo, without any legal status in the US. Why not read the document in the article?

In any case, if you have a better explanation, I'm all ears. But it really doesn't compute here.

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by gridlockd on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:36AM (#24481641)
I think a better explanation is that this is a doctor who specializes in hysterectomies and who recommends hysterectomies whenever that isn't outright malpractice, because it's a routine procedure and it pays relatively well.

This isn't uncommon practice. Hysterectomies often aren't strictly necessary, just like tonsillectomies, back surgeries or hip replacements.

There is no evidence for this really being "masses" of women, or that any of these procedures were entirely unjustified, or that any of this is happening systematically.

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by happytoexplain on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:32AM (#24481595)
>I honestly don't know what to say to someone who thinks the USA is systematically sterilising people.

You should consider that it's possible, rather than accusing that person of essentially being insane. If they were claiming that the US population was being sterilized by something the federal government puts in the water, then sure. But surgical sterilization in these conditions does not require an Illuminati level of conspiracy, and it's over simplistic and dismissive to imply that it does.

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by justinclift on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:23AM (#24478117)
> I honestly don't know what to say to someone who thinks the USA is systematically sterilising people.

Unfortunately, there appears to be evidence of it. :(

eg: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_sterilization#Unite...

That's just a starting point, as it contains both historical info through to the last few years. It gives plenty of references to investigate further though, in case that's of interest.

[dead]
Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by justinclift on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @03:53PM (#24485979)
Hang on. You made out that you don't believe the US has done forced sterilisations. But then respond that it's something you learned about in high school?

eg you've literally learned this stuff has happened in the US before, but you can't believe there are people around doing it now?

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by aaron695 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @04:33PM (#24486384)
> Do you say it because of true stories we know about the past and are are taught history repeats itself. Do you think it's true on rote?

I asked why from true stories from the past you would apply it to the current day to this situation.

With stating factoids, you still have to think how it applies.

When have hysterectomies been used for sterilisation?

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by mitjak on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @10:31AM (#24481578)
we have a limited set of evidence and hysterectomies are one recent example. we just might know facts about other hospitals at this point. do you honestly expect the government to be an stellar example of transparency when it comes to forced sterilization??

you seem to think there are other explanations. care to share?

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by croon on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @04:28AM (#24479046)
> Who would be doing this? Why? How?

Maybe for the same expressed reason they separated children from their parents? Deterrence (which does not work), and sadism (unstated, but obvious).

Re:Whistleblower: Mass Hysterectomies at ICE Facility by ardy42 on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @11:43AM (#24482540)
> Not political at all? Do we really think the USA is running something close to a Experimental Concentration Camp? Exactly what are they experimenting on, what don't we know about hysterectomies?

I think is 1) this story is probably true, 2) it is not the result of any kind of explicit national policy. My guess is the real problem here is malpractice by the gynecologist coupled with a criminal lack of competent oversight by the prison officials. My understanding is prisons scrape the bottom of the barrel of the medical profession (i.e. hiring doctors with bad records that no one else wants), and the actual complaint focuses on one doctor:

> According to Wooten, ICDC consistently used a particular gynecologist – outside the facility – who almost always opted to remove all or part of the uterus of his female detainee patients.

> “Everybody he sees has a hysterectomy—just about everybody,” Wooten said, adding that, “everybody’s uterus cannot be that bad.”

> “We’ve questioned among ourselves like goodness he’s taking everybody’s stuff out…That’s his specialty, he’s the uterus collector. I know that’s ugly…is he collecting these things or something…Everybody he sees, he’s taking all their uteruses out or he’s taken their tubes out. What in the world.”

IMHO, people who are saying (at this point) that this is the result of a systematic policy are jumping to conclusions. If that's true, it'll probably take a least a few weeks for the investigations to confirm it.