This shit is why I don't sell on eBay anymore.
I have a friend who sells stuff on eBay a lot (or at least, used to), and he says about 5% of his sales go to scammers who will request refunds claiming they never received an item.
Of course, now that I think more on it, I wonder how many of those 5% were scammers versus how many of them simply had their package stolen from their front door.
Why would we (I'm genuinely asking here) consider PayPal more similar to CC than the others? My point being, it could be (closer to) either, and both make sense to me. PP doesn't necessarily need to operate like CC.
After all, CC as a service charges much more with processing fees from merchants and sometimes annual fees from the customers. It's meant to provide a "better/premium" service.
PayPal does have a 6 month purchase protection policy in many cases. So... maybe, if you manage to argue that this was a purchase that you're entitled to protection for. But that's a different channel and probably a different physical department at the company.
The payment is authorized by the author (i.e. his PP account wasn't stolen), the whole thing being a scam is irrelevant and PayPal shouldn't be the judge here (if you got scammed and send some physical items to the scammer, can you ask the post office to take it back?)
I sold digital goods on eBay a few times (like, less than 10 times) and I've already got 3 (!) people claiming their purchase is "unauthorized" after I sent them the goods (redeem codes, so I can't really let them "return"). I'm more than glad that PayPal took my stance instead of giving them chargeback, since they're likely trying to scam me.