Re:OpenPGP in Rust: The Sequoia Project
by upofadown on Saturday September 12, 2020 @07:05PM
(#24456681)
Age/Rage is not a standard at all. It is just a program. It definitely has nothing to do with a project intended to implement a particular standard. It is a non-sequitor here.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
PGP is a giant blob of byzantine implementation details and layers of accrued crust that people call a standard by convention and out of inertia.
Being a giant blob of byzantine implementation details and layers of accrued crust doesn't take away from PGP being a standard. Take a look at BMP or Postscript/PDF or even Email and tell me they're not the same.
Parent's point still stands: PGP is a standard (with widespread adoption, mind you) whereas Age is not. Whether it is a good standard or not depends on how you're using it.
The parent's point was that age is 'just a program' and thus not a standard, with no mention of adoption. But PGP is arguably less of a standard than age, by that metric. As to adoption, PGP has very little adoption for actually securing anything (rather than performative use) and for those uses it's trivially replaceable because it's not actually good at them - that's pretty much the motivation behind things like 'age'.