News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Traits of good remote leaders by api on Thursday September 10, 2020 @07:51AM (#24431360)
I am hoping remote work will “nerf” in person charisma. It’s not that charisma is bad, but in person it often seems to overcome any other concern. I have seen so many examples of total fools who nevertheless gain power and leadership on charisma alone. It has the power to overcome reason and speak directly to the brain stem.
Re:Traits of good remote leaders by blaser-waffle on Thursday September 10, 2020 @09:30AM (#24432162)
I've been remote for ~5 years, and in mostly-remote orgs during those times. You can ABSOLUTELY bully people remotely, dominate conversations, and play games.

Leave someone off the invite, have side-bar convos via slack without people knowing, mute people in calls -- and being the loudest, pushiest person in the room absolutely works on skype if the meeting presenter won't mute you.

Re:Traits of good remote leaders by jacknews on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:10AM (#24431507)
Exactly this.

Remote working does remove some of the rapport and chemistry from relationships, which is regrettable, but on the other hand it also reduces the ability for people to 'dominate the room', intimidate, etc.

These kinds of people are sometimes intellectual giants, but very often simply bullies.

Re:Traits of good remote leaders by vsareto on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:54AM (#24431860)
I think it's the other way, the rapport and chemistry allow you to resist someone when they're (consciously or not) dominating the room. You're more easily divided if you don't have that with your coworkers.
Re:Traits of good remote leaders by jacknews on Thursday September 10, 2020 @09:02AM (#24431924)
I think you're in a bad place if things have devolved to a herd-metality us-vs-them.

But I find well-aimed questions can often derail attempts to railroad a situation from a position of power, and it can be very uncomfortable to field those questions in an in-person setting. Much less so remotely.

Re:Traits of good remote leaders by srtjstjsj on Thursday September 10, 2020 @02:37PM (#24435238)
It's both.
Re:Traits of good remote leaders by throwaway0a5e on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:22AM (#24431588)
Something else will replace it. The people who are effective on calls, emails and chat will get the brownie points instead.
Re:Traits of good remote leaders by mwcampbell on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:28AM (#24431632)
Sure, but being effective in calls, emails, and chat requires fewer advantages from factors that aren't under your control. Consider that on an audio-only call, a blind person can be just as effective as a sighted person, if not more so (edit: until sighted people learn to go without visual cues as if they were blind). And in email or text chat, a person with a thick accent, a person with a speech impediment, or a deaf person can be as effective as someone who speaks well in the team's common language.
Re:Traits of good remote leaders by ZephyrBlu on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:52AM (#24431839)
I can't quite pinpoint it, but something feels off about this reasoning.

No matter what, some group of people is going to be at a disadvantage. It doesn't really make sense to me that you want everyone to specifically cater for the minority, as opposed to the majority.

Trying to somewhat accommodate everyone? Great. Forcing changes to accommodate minorities? Doesn't really make sense to me.

Re:Traits of good remote leaders by mwcampbell on Thursday September 10, 2020 @09:02AM (#24431920)
Here are the best responses I can give to that:

1. Fully abled people are already, as John Scalzi put it (with regard to another category), playing on the lowest difficulty setting, across all of their lives. SO I think it's not so bad to take away some advantages, to level the playing field.

2. There are different kinds of disadvantages. There are disadvantages from skills you haven't yet learned, and there are disadvantages from abilities you can never have. What I propose is to replace the latter category for some people with the former category for others. Of course, if biotech someday allows us to give physical abilities to people who don't have them, that changes the equation. And perhaps my thick accent example was weak; my understanding is that it's possible, with great difficulty, to change one's accent.

Re:Traits of good remote leaders by raziel2p on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:59AM (#24431902)
"Everyone" kind of includes minorities. And how do you define "trying"? Is making social media posts on diversity enough to qualify as trying, even if your hiring process only hires white dudes?
Re:Traits of good remote leaders by api on Friday September 11, 2020 @03:56PM (#24446687)
I definitely agree with this general thought. I can't say this with any certainty, but I have developed the impression that a large part of charisma is either genetic or early-developmental and is very hard to learn. People just either have the "reality distortion field" or they don't.

I have seen people suddenly develop this trait on amphetamines, but ruining your health by abusing amphetamine to have charisma isn't a great trade. This observation does make me wonder if it doesn't have something to do with dopamine levels/sensitivity and whatever other systems amphetamine acts upon. People with bipolar disorder can be superhumanly charismatic when they are in a manic phase, and moderate to heavy amphetamine doses more or less approximate mania (in people without ADD/ADHD).

Like height and facial symmetry it's a trait that is unrelated to the content of one's mind but heavily biases people toward you in one on one interactions... regardless of the merit of what you're actually saying or doing.

Re:Traits of good remote leaders by mdifrgechd on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:54AM (#24431861)
I've thought about this too. The voice and content that dominates in online discussions for example is very different than my experience with in-person collaboration. I don't know if it's better or worse, but different skills are needed to be effective, and they are not necessarily correlated with having the best ideas or being best at the job. So there will be a new equilibrium point that will benefit some and set others back. But I dont see it being more or less fair in the end.
Re:Traits of good remote leaders by dongping on Thursday September 10, 2020 @09:04AM (#24431948)
Yes, indeed, having a peck order in group is natural.

The different favorable trait would then have effect on the productivity, though. Asynchronous communication is way more friendlier to deep work like programming.

Re:Traits of good remote leaders by extremeMath on Thursday September 10, 2020 @08:01AM (#24431443)
Meh, I have that in person charisma. I get a bit panicky online because you can't see someone's face.

I don't know if I'm talking too much or if they are bored. Online I'm quick/short.

That said, I enjoy being a tech guy over a leader. I tried leadership in done personal business and I don't like playing politics or psychology tricks.

Re:Traits of good remote leaders by mwcampbell on Thursday September 10, 2020 @11:30AM (#24433237)
Since I'm visually impaired (legally blind), I always have that uncertainty you described, even in person. I'm often conscious that I might be talking too much. At some point you just learn to live with it.